This thread is ridiculous. The judges were not aware of how the public had voted when they made their decisions. Also, Aiden was terrible. While Simon's crush on Cheryl helped him make the right decision, Louis didn't have the guts to vote Aiden out because he's too much of a wimp to face the backlash of the deranged public who hate Katie for no reason and like Aiden because he's 'good looking' or whatever.