..... especially if katie derserved three.

surely katie will go next week.

I agree. I liked his performances esp Diamonds are Forever. I would have liked to see a few more atleast.

Of course he did.

Saving someone who has consistantly been in the bottom two for weeks stinks

Katie will be in the bottom 2/3 next week, and I guarantee that $imon will vote her out.

What a joke Only advantage is that Aiden won't be so tainted by the X-Factor-so-not-credible brush.

I have said that for the last two weeks

Ding Dong the witch isn't dead yet

Another to fall at the hands of the Beast, the Antiwagner, the Katie.

While Wagner remains though, she will always be pushed into the shadows of the bottom 2, and she can not hide from the light of truth for much longer.

disagree, he was not appreciated so he is best shot of it as he is toooooooo talented.

Katie rocks.

There is no point in having the sing off unless the person who performed best in it is saved. Katie performed the best and deserved to be saved.

Might as well scrap the sing off and go straight to the judges vote otherwise.

he has been there by the skin of his teeth every week no doubt and he was outsung when it mattered, thats how it goes wether people agree with it or not. Anyway, the public decided and so he obviously wasnt as popular as many people assumed to think.

Without a doubt he deserved a second chance.

Shame on Simon and the judges for not saving him.

Yes he did, but unfortunatley for us the media who are stuck up SC's backside would rather write about the whiney one. SC knows this show is tired and it has never been a talent show, so kicking out the most attention seeking contestant they have probably ever had would be a bad move.

I agree, I don't like Aidan and think his singing is terrible but he deserved another chance as it was his first week in the bottom 2, compared to Katie who has had too many chances already.

Well, whatever happens here on in, Katie has proven herself and she has won out against the knockers. No one can take any credit when she does go now as their claims are unfounded and simply bullying brought about by press pressure.

Someone should maybe remind the judges of that then because some weeks they do not judge on the sing off, SC being the worst offender.

It is NOT a charitable event, its a vocal competition (tell wagner voters) and wether he had been in the bottom two before or not, he sang terribly.

Are you suggesting they be thrown at her?

damn right he did

If Kattie desserves 4 chances. Then someone who imo has more talent and charisma in his quiff than she does in her whole body desserved at least one

Well people who voted didn't seem to think he deserved a second chance.

I agree.

Simon obviously didnt think he did deserve a second chance. He knew it would go to deadlock as Cheryl would vote to keep Katie, and Danni would vote to keep Aiden, and he knew that Louis would vote to keep Aiden as well this week.
Therefore he knew it would go to the public vote.

The question then is: Did he know Aiden had the least public votes?
We shall never know.

Hadn't he murdered enough songs already Giving him another chance would have been criminal - assault on my ears

At the end of the day if Aiden was that popular he would never had been in the bottom two.

If the vote was one to 'evict' contestants, there would be merit in your statement. However, since the vote is a positive one there is the possibility that Aiden's fans were a bit complacent ( assuming he was safe this early on )

I know I was

He deserved a second chance based on that possibility alone

Then those who didn't vote only have themselves to blame.

This is what annoys me, We don't yet know what Katies singing next week or how good/bad it will be but some want her out This is why the show is now crap, viewers are asked to vote on performance, but some have made up their minds already

Viewers are ruining the X Factor and blaming Cowell for it.