That would be my perfect final as well. Scott is good, but for some reason that I can't quite put my finger on he doesn't excite me, and I haven't really enjoyed many of his dances at all.

I'm not feeling the Matt performance, so I can't agree he is better. Infact, I think Scott out-performs both Matt and Kara by a country mile, though the girl is making definate inroads in that area.

From his spell-bound VW to his masterful Tango to his Jack-the-lad Jive, we have seen so many convincing Scott personas. The dancing farmer "wahaay, I can unicycle" doesnt come close to the stage performances Scott is pulling off week after week.

Granted, Matt is not an actOR, but nor was Chris Hollins and yet, technique aside, he still managed to perform one of the most vulnerably romantic Rumbas SCD has produced. And no one has smouldered quite like cricketer Mark.

I only saw that dance yest (yes- Im slow) and I thought it was fab!!!

Have to say Im not a scott or Natalie fan when I see them separately but together I think they make a great partnership!

100% agree.

I thought the dance was amazing, Natalie is amazingly good at choreography and Scott is technically brilliant. I have watched it several times on you tube since.

I kinda dont get the thrill from watching Scott - I think its because Natalie outshines him - she is so over him you dont get a chance to notice his dancing. Or else maybe its just that he doesnt have the personality?

For me the best two celebs now are Kara 1...Matt close 2nd.

Scott's jive was very good. Unfortunately, he just can't move his hips. His Rumba was horrible and his Samba wasn't much better. I don't think he deserves to win now, as most of his Latin just isn't up to scratch.

So what.....Just because he has one area where he is not great at , does not mean he can't win the show.

It's not professional dancers being judged here. None of the celebs who are in the show are perfect in everything,

Everyone lacks something. It's about improving on what you can do. Let's not get carried way, Scott is not terrible in Latin. After all his best dance was after all in Latin.

He just had one really bad dance in the Rumba. His Samba was not the best but I've enjoyed it.

I think you are comparing him with Matt who is gymnastic and there were quite few gymnastic moves in his Samba tonight.

His Samba was bad IMO. If he can't move his hips, then his Cha Cha won't be great either. I think a versatile dancer should win. Kara is probably the best dancer overall. Matt's Samba was a bit blah for me, but it was much better than Scott's.

I like both guys (though Kara's my absolute favourite) and I loved Scott's jive last week. In fact that ranks as my favourite jive in a really long time! This week I thought Matt did the better job of the samba, and not because he did three backflips at the end of his routine. His hip movement was better than Scott's and so was his arm placement, which is slowly beginning to look more like dancing and less like the finish of a gymnastic move. The two of them are very talented though. I'm clearly in the minority, but I couldn't pick one over the other at the moment because I change my mind pretty much weekly! Battle of the sambas and rumbas I'd give to Matt. Battle of the Viennese Waltzes goes to Scott, and I'd be surprised if I didn't award battle of the jives to him as well.

I disagree, I think Scott has shown brilliance in both ballroom and Latin. which tells me he is versatile, he also has something which the others don't, the ability to give an dance the wow factor with great choreography and character.

I'm not going disagree about Kara, she is brilliant and I want her in the final along side Scott.

I really hope all three (Scott, Kara and Matt) are in the final. They are all brilliant in their own ways (Matt won me over a bit tonight), and it would be nice to have a final that was...less contentious?...than the last 2 or 3 years have been.