On extrafactor all you hear is mat from essex but nobdy says anything about this.

And how Mary need the Irish votes -- no mention of that either

Every one else has had to do all sorts of songs, Cher has had slow ballads, raps, dancers, no dancers, Matt has had 'unplugged' weeks, wearing a vest week, dancers etc.

Even Wagner has had a ballad week with no dancers.


How come Rebecca can still just do the standing still?

Cher = ballads = crap
Cher = rap = even crapper
Wagner = singing with dancers = awful
Wagner = ballad = bad
Matt = dancing = bad
Matt = vest = embarrasing
Matt = singing still = great

I imagine then if Rebecca surrounds the stage with dancers as she sings, then falls to the floor, forgets her words and cries, she's gonna win easily. Might be a good idea, get labelled genius and the performance of the season.

Cos the judges are biased scumbags who dont play by their own rules

I think Wagners main singing issue is language and song choice. When he sang the longer notes of Creep, he actually sounded good

But Louis ruined him with OTT performances, and songs with too many words

Wagner definitely trumps Rebecca as a performer neways!

And now you must be disappointed?

I could hardly believe how someone could sing that song and remain so static.


Because it's usually part of any singer's performance, a means to connect with their audience.

As I've already said elsewhere, I'm a Rebecca fan (as far as her voice and potential are concerned) but I find it frustrating to see how poorly she performs or connects with the audience. I have been waiting for this side of her to develop and it just hasn't done so. I don't need to see her gyrating around in some spectacular choreographed show, but it would be nice to see her walk across the stage and project herself to her audience.

I reckon that this is why some people are saying they find her boring and dull. To me, she doesn't inspire any kind of excitement. Last night she was compared to Aretha Franklin but think about how far she has to travel to reach the sort of performance level to reach Aretha's standard in performance.


This. In a nutshell.

Its not her style to be jumping all over the place,she is a classy singer and if she wants to just move a little so be it,i like the singing not the dancing.

I don't think its Matt's style to be running around the stage with 100 dancers either, but he had to do it?

But thats down to the mentor,

About time for the funky chicken from her