another killing of a good tune

Yeah, it's one of my favourite REM as well.

that really was BAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She almost hit some of the notes as well!!!!

very true hurt my ears

It's as much the fact that they chopped and changed the song in order to cram it into the time slot. What with that, and Louis not knowing what the hell the lyrics to creep are......

she was meddling the lyrics up too!

She has killed my ears that was awfull.

Why is Cheryl nearly in tears watching it? She looked like like a bulldog sucking on a nettle dipped in Simon poo.

no no no you're not alone. my head hurts.

for once simon speaks without his forked tongue

If she can't hit notes that even Stipe can manage to hit, then she has no chance.

Of COURSE it meant loads to her !

What the hell do they see in her, bigging her up like this every time... she's rubbish!

That was terrible, I thought she'd forgotten the words, and the judges still praise her!!

but she's had such a terrible time with the press this week, give her a break (Louis quotes twice)

She always sounding so desperate.
I get that she's shaky because of bad press, but it's just so needy, begging-like.

pretty stupid comment...

well lets face it...away from x factor manipulation would you:-
buy a cd of hers
pay money to see her in a concert.
for me answer would be no and no
so what is the point of her still being there other than to annoy the hell out of the majority

Pretty stupid response considering Automatic for the people was released in 1992.

Ahhh you edited your comment to prevent yourself from looking like an arse. Well done!!!