I enjoyed Matt's dance as a spectacle but as I fast forward all the talking and rubbish, and only watch the dances and scoring, I genuinely didn't know what kind of dance it was meant to be until coming onto these boards today. American Smmoth - really??? I had guessed an avant garde foxtrot, but it was more like a sort of slowish show dance.
The judges comments to him were over-harsh though. They were within their rights to mark him down because it wasn't a proper AS and to say that, but they seemed to mark him down for having a tense face and some other non-described reasons, that as TV judges, they should be able to properly articulate to TV audiences.