I normally quite like Danni as a judge, but I thought she was unbelievably rude to Wagner after what was undoubtedly his best performance. I thought it was totally uncalled for to be honest to be so personally rude to a contestant.

Shame on you Miss Minogue!

P.m.t

yes dannii used to be my fave judge, but she is just so cold and mean this year.

i dont like her, and shes getting annoying.

Although ill always prefer her to saint cheryl

Her mask is slipping this series

The only positive thing about her comment to Wagner was that she didn't come out with that old "Last week we had the wedding, now the reception, what can we expect next week" . I think part of Dannii's problem is she believes she's funny and comes out with cringeworthy comments and acts likes she's in her twenties. I think she should stick to just judging the performance without trying too hard to be witty because she actually is a very credible judge.

I noticed that wandering hand thing she does on front of Louis came back tonight :yawn:

She was joking a bit but you know Louis picked the song for him and knowing the situation, what did he expect them to say?

I'm warming more to Dannii as the weeks pass. She's now the only judge who actually gives an opinion on the performance. Simon seems to have disappeared up his own backside, Cheryl just sits there going "luv luv luv luv luv" and Louis gives the impression of being higher than the Space Station.

If that means she's occasionally rude so be it. Wagner is man enough to take it.

I am starting to like Dannii. she is letting the polite bullshit go and going with the flow.

oh god yeah - that really does my baps in as well

she shouldn't have gone there though - we all heard the lyrics and no doubt many of us were laughing to ourselves about it but it wasn't necessary to make the comment on live TV

Agree with this.

I just thought it was hilarious that Louis thought the lyrics were "I'm a winner". What a complete arse!

What she said what totally rude and unnecessary. It was a personal attack at him, a cheap shot that had nothing to do with his performance.

Shame, I usually like Dannii too

Yeh and whats with that silly snap snap crocodile thing she has started to do to Loui it is starting to get silly and annoying, grow up Ms Minogue.

I wonder if people will call that bullying since Cheryl's "attack" () on Wagner last week was classed as "bullying" by people on here Ok so she shouldn't have said it but come on ...

What did she say to him that was so gobsmackingly horrific and rude?

Here here, don't know how Loui puts up with it I would say something to her and tell her no-one is amused by it so stop doing it, she just looks silly now.

what gets me with danni is how she sits there slagging off people who have more talent than her! she sang other peoples songs and has rode on her sisters coat tails all these years!!
where exactly is danni's talent?
and dont get me started on princess " i'v got a big chip on my shoulder" cheryl !!!,

Dannii can actually sing very well. There is a clip of her performing in theatre on YouTube and she is actually a very accomplished singer. Far better than Princess.

Oh and incidentally, she was famous before Kylie and has been in showbiz for 30-odd years. Hardly riding on Kylie's coat tails.

The definition of rudeness was bifa when she pulled Wagner up for his so called council house comment to the press. She was vile.

that wasn't rudeness though, that was just sheer vindictiveness

I've always loved Dannii, even when Cheryl first came along and everyone was raving over her. But something's changed with her this year. I don't like to say it because I've been such a Dannii shipper for a long time, but she's just being rude unneccessarily.

Even if she is rude, she's the least rude of the 4.

Don't always agree with you but i like your honesty

I didn't notice that she was supposedly rude??

I often come onto the forums though after the show and seem to have missed the apparent "tension" between the judges. Perhaps that is because I am not really that interested in what they say anymore sadly - I just switch off. Most of what they do say is for pantomime effect anyway and the moment that I realised that, they became totally unpersuasive and uninteresting to me.

"It isn't a song which fits the theme"..."you made it your own"..."your mentor isn't looking after you"...blah, blah, blah, blah.....**eyes glazing over**

it was embarressing. And pointless. it was not vindictiveness. seriously what is the matter with people.
Cheryl's not evil or cruel. She's just a moany cow.
Wagner can handle himself.