i really hope not

Of course she would, the same against Mary too. I would have thought that was pretty obvious.

Yes, yes and triple yes.

There would be a case of we've saved her so far so why not continue. Plus we all know they want Wagner out.

I'm sure she would be if she were up against Wagner - and quite rightly so as well - but I'm not so sure with Mary, I think that one could go either way,

Plus the overiding fact that she is a better singer, suppose people conveniently forget that or will everyone be rushing out to buy a Mary or Wagner CD? No, they wont.

I think if Katie was to go tonight in a sing-off, it would have to be against 1D or Cher. Matt and Rebecca will be safe I presume, and the judges would save her over Wagner and Mary.

I would think so. But to be honest, you just never know. For all Simon's posturing he knows Wagner is good for publicity and controversy and might just do a Jedward and save him.

Of course she would... she's a fighter after all.

Without a doubt.

Yes. He's her last chance of survival.

I think it's far too late in the competition for him to do that tbh.

They need to weigh up their ever dwindling 'credibility' (ahem) with their terribly transparent attempts at manipulation.

I think they would have to let Katie go. Or at least allow deadlock.

Of course she would they have invested too much in to her and they hate Wagner! I hope he is well clear of the bottom 3 positions!

She would be saved. But the backlash against her by the viewing public would be massive.

Unfortunately, yes Which is WHY we have to KEEP VOTING FOR WAGNER!

And you have the audacity to therefore infer that people will rush out to buy Katie's CD? Get a grip. This is a popularity contest, not an album sales barometer - and Katie is not popular. Singing ability and XFactor are contradictory terms.

Yes. There's no way would Dannii save Wagner.

It's getting close to the end now so I think she might be sent home against anyone else.

Why do people think/spend so much time working out why the 6th and seventh placed acts are saved or not or indeed who they are, its irrelevant, the final three is all that matters.

I think saving Katie over Mary would be controversial.

Won't happen though as I expect Katie to come last in the vote.

Sadly the answer is yes

But his name will be called out as safe

Of course she will. She will be saved against Mary too. And I wouldn't be surprised if she was saved against matt (if he's in bottom with her) the only ones she won't be saved against are cheryls other girls and one direction. She had Simons protection.

Not what I said. More people would buy Kaites than Marys or Wagners for sure, no matter their protestations! And, FYI, judging by this forum, the success is not considered until album sales have been mulled over and compared to previous winners.

I see what you mean by your last statement, so Leona Lewis cannot sing? and is simply a nice popular person instead? The same for A Burke?
Thats how they won, so pleased to have this issue cleared up once and for all.

Its not going to matter. Katie will be dead last this week. She won't have the chance to be saved

Louis wouldn't save Katie over Mary - and nor would Dannii I expect. So it would go to deadlock.

She would be saved over mary as well,talk about a cat with 9 lives.