Of course she would, and all hell will break loose for Cowell.
Would katie be saved a 5th time if she is in the sing off with wagner ?
2 of 2
YES - She would be saved against Wagner 100%.
Against Mary however, it would go to the public vote, as I believe Dannii would vote to SAVE Mary.
Against Mary however, it would go to the public vote, as I believe Dannii would vote to SAVE Mary.
Against anyone else, there's no real point in saving Katie anymore. She has served her purpose and now the ratings should be carried by the fact that we're approaching the end.
Originally Posted by CloudyE:
“Plus the overiding fact that she is a better singer, suppose people conveniently forget that or will everyone be rushing out to buy a Mary or Wagner CD? No, they wont.”
“Plus the overiding fact that she is a better singer, suppose people conveniently forget that or will everyone be rushing out to buy a Mary or Wagner CD? No, they wont.”
She's not a better singer than TreyC or (IMO) Aiden yet saw them off.
The reason so many people are voting for Wagner is because she's been saved against singers who have been far better than her - Cowell seems to have failed to notice however.
Originally Posted by Stratosphere:
“She's not a better singer than TreyC or (IMO) Aiden yet saw them off.
The reason so many people are voting for Wagner is because she's been saved against singers who have been far better than her - Cowell seems to have failed to notice however.”
“She's not a better singer than TreyC or (IMO) Aiden yet saw them off.
The reason so many people are voting for Wagner is because she's been saved against singers who have been far better than her - Cowell seems to have failed to notice however.”
All in your opinion, and that couldnt possibly be wrong could it! Just becasue people make a lot of noise on here, it doesnt mean that this IS the total UK descision an an act.
Treyc, Aidan, Rebecca, One Direction and Matt, I would still ONLY buy a cd by Katie as she has a vocal style I like, the others dont.
I'm not sure really. They know that people can't stand Katie, and saving her again will look dreadful, but they do want Wagner out. That said, they think he will definately go next week, so they might save him this time.
Originally Posted by Stratosphere:
“She's not a better singer than TreyC or (IMO) Aiden yet saw them off.
The reason so many people are voting for Wagner is because she's been saved against singers who have been far better than her - Cowell seems to have failed to notice however.”
“She's not a better singer than TreyC or (IMO) Aiden yet saw them off.
The reason so many people are voting for Wagner is because she's been saved against singers who have been far better than her - Cowell seems to have failed to notice however.”
Oh give me Katie over TreyC and Aiden any day. Aiden has potential, IMO but TreyC was just not 'that' good and I don't know whether she could have improved any.
2 of 2
