Katie - she's been in the bottom two about three times too many now! I've had enough of her and just want rid.

One Direction - Something just doesn't wash with me, and as much as I dislike the vocal stylings of Matt and Mary at least they do sing.

wand erection and katie

One Direction: It's not as much that they're not very good, more that they're being told they're fantastic that's bugging me.

Cher: I think Cher is marmite, you'll either love or hate her performances with rap. Personally I hate them. And goodness knows, one Cheryl is enough.

Anyone really. I don't care. They were all pretty craptastic last night with the exception of the two second songs by Matt and Rebecca.

But from a dynamics perspective, two of cheryl's to go to level the playing field and put Louis in the smug seat.

Just for kicks.

Cher and Katie. Both are rubbish and it would be hilarious if they went.

Katie
I'm sorry but when in any other x factor has a contestant been given this many chances! I'm sure last year or the year before simon sent Rachel home because even though he liked her he admitted the public didn't so he couldn't work with that. Every week we get the new "this is me" and the predictable tears and begging and the annoying thing is it seems to work! Paije..Aiden...Treyc have all behaved with dignity when doing their sing off and have been sent home. I cannot stand Katie -what she did last night to kings of leon and REM was unforgivable.

ps i know it isnt her fault what her family do..but her parents constant moaning to the press just makes her own situation worse and her granny is a prossie...get this wierd family away from me!


Hard to pick a second choice really but probably Mary because she isn't realistically what their looking for despite what Simon says about the over-28s

Katie - shes distinctly average, didnt deserve to go through at judges house stage and should never have been chosen over Treyc, aiden (yes twas public on this one) or paige.

Mary - wonderful powerhouse of a voice but I just wouldnt miss her performances at all. I would however, enjoy her in the background at a nice posh wedding or she could be in the west end... playing the jailor in rent or was it chicago?

Cher - don't like her performances or her look.

Katie - she can only sing when she's begging and pleading - it's boring now.

Cher and katie.

One Direction - they haven't really demonstrated enough talent or stage-presence for me. The backing track takes away any human personality from the performances. They seem to have so much cocky attitude in the behind the scenes footage, but stand on the stage like 5 mannequins.

Wagner - the joke is over. He's taking up valuable time and effort from more promising acts who have the potential for a career in the industry. Don't really like the God references either.

Katie first, with Cher V Rebecca as 2nd and 3rd bottom.

Just to make Cheryl cry and swear at Wagner, Nations Sweetheart tag officially down the toilet.

I know people hate Wagner and i admit he isn't my favourite, but last night he won me over with his first song. He was better then even Rebecca.

So based on last night

Katie: Boring ME now.

Mary: I like her as a person, but her songs bore me.

I thought Cher did very well. 1D are obviously not going anywhere. Rebecca was boring but her vocals are ok.

Matt just has it.

I really don't care, I have nothing against any of the contestants, as long as Wag goes through I'll be happy.

OP I really liked your post though...fair, balanced, reasoned and well thought out. You still got attacked for it though!

I don't watch the Xtra Factor, so literally all I see from the contestants is on ITV on the live shows.

I started off as a Matt/Aiden fan. Aiden went and my interest dropped. For some reason Matt has stopped ticking the boxes for me. I feel like he's not being 'true' to himself, in that he doesn't strike me as a ballad singing male solo artist, more of a frontman in a band. (I've heard some of his old group's stuff - it's more my kind of music.) So I think he'd be better being eliminated in the next few weeks, so he's still got a chance to do the music he wants, rather than what Cowell sees him doing. I don't want him to win it.

I'd like to finally get rid of Katie tonight - if she survives, it really will put me off the show.

In a way, I'd like Wagner to win. Just to put Cowell's nose out of joint, the way he did with many viewers in saving Katie so many times (and also what he did to Paije.)

Katie - her time was up long ago and she's outstayed her welcome

Cher - never warmed to her, think her rapping is laughable and really don't like her voice or attitude

Katie - Too many times in the bottom 2, must be her time to go.

Wagner - It's getting beyond a joke now. Get him out

Thank you

Yes, I made the mistake of being a Matt fan. Naughty me!

Cher/Wagner - not too bothered which.
Katie definitely should go - she murdered two great songs last night!

Matt & Rebecca

Both excellent and the biggest threat to Cher winning (though I'm not fussed if she doesn't as she's the only one with a realistic successful future).

I like your thinking. Eliminate the competition

Katie and Cher, Katie to have the lowest votes and Cher to be in the bottom 2 with Rebecca and Cher to get voted off. Imagine how gutted Biffa would be to lose katie outright and then have cher and rebecca in the bottom too! she'd be fuming!

TV Gold

Exactly

However, chances of it happening is another matter!

Cher and Katie

Both talentless - and Cher should have gone last week when she was blown out of the water by the more talented Paije.

I haven't forgiven Cowell for that

Ideally Wagner and Katie but would be happy to see Katie and Cher go just to even things up a bit (and to wipe the smug smile from Cheryls face)

wagner because good singers are going before him
katie or cher because they are over hyped