Katie - Very poor again last night, about time she went.
Mary - So incredibly over-rated, very poor last night again.
Mary - So incredibly over-rated, very poor last night again.
We lose 2 tonight. Which 2 do you WANT it to be and why?
3 of 4
Katie & Mary.
Katie, because I've had enough of her drama. Mary, cos she does Jack for me. Her voice is too shouty at times. Nice woman and all, but wouldn't miss her if she's not there.
Katie, because I've had enough of her drama. Mary, cos she does Jack for me. Her voice is too shouty at times. Nice woman and all, but wouldn't miss her if she's not there.
Originally Posted by MARTYM8:
“Cher and 1 Direction - they can't sing and Cher is unlikeable!”
“Cher and 1 Direction - they can't sing and Cher is unlikeable!”
^^^^^ This for me.
Pretty well the same reasons too
I want Katie and Cher to go. Have had enough of them. I may start watching again if Katie goes, havnt watched since Aidens departure. Can't take katie's existence there while aiden went over her coz of Simon cow unfairly saving her.
I'd lose Cher (sorry, can't stand her) and Rebecca (she's lovely, bound to do well anyway though, and I just don't like her voice or style very much - she's good, but not my bag).
And then Cheryl can give all her time to Katie.
And then Cheryl can give all her time to Katie.
Katie - Preferably the first to go, with no sing-off. She doesn't deserve a final performance, she's had too bloody many of them.
Then: Cher and 1D, fantasy bottom two to shake up Simon and Cheryl. Cher going.
I actually quite like Cher, but it would be 'Job well done, public' if Cheryl lost two of her acts tonight and Simon realised 1D weren't able to win.
Then: Cher and 1D, fantasy bottom two to shake up Simon and Cheryl. Cher going.
I actually quite like Cher, but it would be 'Job well done, public' if Cheryl lost two of her acts tonight and Simon realised 1D weren't able to win.
Originally Posted by Lizzy11268:
“My personal choice would be to say goodbye to the following:
Katie : Its not like she hasnt been given enough chances, and she was pretty rubbish last night. Last week she was good and deserved to stay, same with jungle book week - and the weeks she WAS good she stayed. But she cannot do a good job consistently, and in this as in normal life, if you can't do the job, in the words of Lord Sugar "you're fired".
Wagner : I have a lot of respect for the brazilian lord, but I think it's time he went home. Having said that, I shan't be overly upset if he goes to the semi finals, it will make for some interesting discussions and much as I don't rate him as a singer, he sure is entertaining.
As for the rest
Cher - I think she raised her game after being in the bottom two and good on her, not my thing at all but I can see her having success with a certain demographic, and her voice is not THAT bad. In fact she's better than some who chart regularly.
Rebecca - Has had her weak performances, notably Beatles week, but overall she has been consistently good in her little bubble and I love her voice and would definitely buy her releases.
Matt - The winner in waiting. He has what X Factor winners need - a top vocal and a top fanbase.
Mary - Not for me, a bit too cruise ship, but she deserves a semi final place.
One Direction - they may be just another boybland but there are a couple of good singers in there and unlike Katie and Wagner I can see them having a fairly successful career in the pop industry.
What does everyone else think?”
“My personal choice would be to say goodbye to the following:
Katie : Its not like she hasnt been given enough chances, and she was pretty rubbish last night. Last week she was good and deserved to stay, same with jungle book week - and the weeks she WAS good she stayed. But she cannot do a good job consistently, and in this as in normal life, if you can't do the job, in the words of Lord Sugar "you're fired".
Wagner : I have a lot of respect for the brazilian lord, but I think it's time he went home. Having said that, I shan't be overly upset if he goes to the semi finals, it will make for some interesting discussions and much as I don't rate him as a singer, he sure is entertaining.
As for the rest
Cher - I think she raised her game after being in the bottom two and good on her, not my thing at all but I can see her having success with a certain demographic, and her voice is not THAT bad. In fact she's better than some who chart regularly.
Rebecca - Has had her weak performances, notably Beatles week, but overall she has been consistently good in her little bubble and I love her voice and would definitely buy her releases.
Matt - The winner in waiting. He has what X Factor winners need - a top vocal and a top fanbase.
Mary - Not for me, a bit too cruise ship, but she deserves a semi final place.
One Direction - they may be just another boybland but there are a couple of good singers in there and unlike Katie and Wagner I can see them having a fairly successful career in the pop industry.
What does everyone else think?”
Love this
Agree with you but would rather keep Wagner and see Mary or Cher (hate her "attitude") go...
Wagner: it's just not funny anymore
Rebecca: good singer but was quite bad last night.
As long as Mary, the best last night and almost every week, stays I will be happy!
Rebecca: good singer but was quite bad last night.
As long as Mary, the best last night and almost every week, stays I will be happy!
Originally Posted by Viridiana:
“Rebecca and Cher. If Cher could be out two times i would love it.”
“Rebecca and Cher. If Cher could be out two times i would love it.”
Like this
Cher and Katie, as a big eff youu to Chezza really. (That and if I hear Cher rap another week I may cry.)
One Direction can go too though. So can Matt.
One Direction can go too though. So can Matt.
Based on vocal ability 1D and Katie
Plus, it would be really interesting to see who Simon would save out of his two fav acts.
Plus, it would be really interesting to see who Simon would save out of his two fav acts.
Originally Posted by laura.mcphee221:
“Rebecca and katie
Both bore me to death and very false.”
“Rebecca and katie
Both bore me to death and very false.”
Rebecca false when even louis walsh keeps saying how nice she is.
Why do you know her then,you know her better than louise.
3 of 4
