They both have very average voices and that's on a good vocal day!

However, which of the two do you think has the better singing voice?

Cheryl - and she has better songs too.
Dannii can't dance either.

Definitely Cheryl . But you know what the majority are going to say...

Danni actually has quite a good singing voice:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oTL2LNXzzZI

Leagues ahead of Cheryl anyway.

That's the only performance anyone can ever come out with in her 20 year long career. It's not even impreesive either.

Dannii will always be the less successful, less liked Minogue.

Doesn't matter that she's been in the industry longer than Kylie, she will always live in her shadow.

I knew what it was before i even clicked it

1 word...nasal. She sounds quite like Kylie.

I knew too, from my days as a lurker that's the one performance that is linked. I could link you too another 100 mimed performances.

Neither really have the X-Factor, nor a patch on the contestants tbh. The show has been a godsend for both.

This thread is equivalent to asking which Ian makes the better babysitter...Huntley or Brady

I think its quite good i think people just critasise dannii because its been so long since shes done something. If she got a better songwritter im sure she could do something really good. much better than cheryl

Dannii is a better singer than Cheryl. She obviously has studio help but at least she sounds good after it unlike Cheryl, who still sounds awful even after all the studio trickery.

Cheryl can perform well, which is her only saving grace, however her performances are always mimed, and when she isn't you can REALLY tell that it is live.

Dannii can actually sing live well and dance ok, she was really good on Dancing With The Stars in Oz. She was also very good on CIN 2006: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EXtLY...eature=related

And at least that was live, which is waaay more than I can say for Cheryl. Even when standing still Cheryl is just diabolical in every sense. Can't even sing her own songs in tune

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UEHqN...eature=related

Oh dear....

dannii can sing live, doesnt have to mime

cheryl cant

danniis songs might not be great but the voice is there

That performance you linked too for Dannii is mimed.

Define successful....

There was a period of time where Dannii was outselling Kylie in aussieland. Read it somewhere. Sure you can google if it you wanna.

But over the long haul then Kylie will obv be successful if you mean earns more.

Similarly - OP please define better singer.

Louder?
Stronger voice?
Sweeter tone?
Hits more right notes more often?
Has a greater vocal range?
Can sing live (without their own vocals on a backing track)?

Watcha after?

#OMG you can hear its live, she just has a backing track in the background to cover up some of her mistakes, but its still better than not singing at all...

yeahh it is live

They're both bad singers. The only difference is....

Kylie- 60m records
Dannii- 2-3m being generous.

I mean the best voice factoring in all of the above!

Kylie is a million times more successful than Dannii. However, Kylie's voice is also average. Probably slightly better than Dannii's though.

Cheryl and she's better dancer too.

Simon said it and while back. It all comes down to song choice. Cheryl knows how to pick her singles. Her dancing is extremely good but that's it.

Neither can sing live- so can I pass.

Here is Cheryl singing live (i.e. truly live no tricks or autotuning) - Wagner has a far superior voice.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bE3LHFG_bjQ

Dannii by far

Like I said in the other thread

dannii grew up singing on telly..I watched her sing live on YTT every week and she certainly can sing

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IbilR6qwxBY

lol so cute