Deeming either one of them singers is an insult. Dannii is the better judge and person. Cheryl is a better dancer. Neither one of them are singers.

Don't know how you can judge who is a better person.

That performance doesn't convince me

Better person may be a bit extreme, but from what I can see, Dannii seems less fake than Cheryl, more decisive and just more of a woman. Cheryl seems like a little girl a lot of the time, throwing tantrums etc.

That would be my judgement.

dude you're taking the piss arent you

the first song is not mimed, if you cant tell the difference thats worrying, there's backtrack vocals, way less than on most of cheryls performances

the question is not who you like the most, or whose music you like the most, thats highly subjective, it's been asked who the better vocalist is and there's no doubt about that...

coz she got 'em out fae the lads innit









LOL Jk, that was a long time ago

Does there have to be a better one? everyones flawed.

Michael Jackson and Beyonce prove otherwise. If there are better live vocalists and performers than them, I haven't seem them.

It is mimed, it sounds identical to the studio version but with an echo on the end. She's hardly speaking.

I debate both Dannii and Cheryl are equally weak singers.

That was just shocking.

Going back to the original question, I think it's obvious who is the better singer.

I'm not a fan of either, but that's not to say I dislike them, I don't - but I do find it amusing how some people on this thread are smoke screening and using diversion tactics to over complicate the question, and it is a very simple and obvious question.

Saying you prefer the genre of someones music over another doesn't answer the question, nor whether such and such is a better dancer/performer! - or in the style of Gaspanic, who is obviously a Cheryl Cole fan, but at least admits her vocals are a lot to be desired, still cannot concede the obvious fact that vocally, Dannii Minogue is relatively superior - instead he/she/it states that they are both bad...

The question is simple, even if you're a fan of CC or DM - Danni Minogue is vocally superior to Cheryl.

They are both bad, I've seen 1 or 2 passable performances by each but that's it. Nobody even knows what Dannii sounds like these days either.

danni is average at best, as i said earlier biffa is dire, you can go to any karaoke bar and find someone who can sing 1000 times better

gocompare.com

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EE96yIPZy3A

Dannii is a way better singer IMO there's a really good live performance of I Begin To Wonder that she sang at party in the park!!!!! But I can't find it which is annoying!!!

Also she is a trained dancer!!! She went to the Johnny young talent school!!!!!

I think it's obvious who can hold a better sustained note. Who has the stronger vibrato and tone and who has the greater range.

I've seen Dannii sing and dance and I'm not overly impressed. I think she is marginally a better vocalist than Cheryl, but Cheryl is definitely a better dancer. However, as a judge on X Factor, Dannii wins hands down. Dannii is far superior to Cheryl class-wise as well.

I can honestly say I prefer Cheryl's voice Dannii sounds just like Kylie and while i love Kylie's music, she can't sing. She signs through her nose and there's only so much you can listen too.

I'm a fan of CC, but i'd say if Dannii was better. CC isn't fantastic but i think she is better than Dannii. She's not dire, come on! She's not got a strong voice, but she's got a melodic pleasant voice with a warm tone to it, bit like Katie Waissel

She's also a better performer. Which she showed in Girls Aloud.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Axzv3cKCeQI

Easily the best dancer of the group.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uamenXuKEHc

just listen to the video, dont watch it, its way more "live" than cheryls promise this at x factor, which was 90% mimed

she's a dire VOCALIST, she's a good performer and a good dancer, but she just can't sing, just get over it!

It's almost all mimed. Undistinguishable live voice with the studio version played really loud in the background to pad out any errors.

Dannii...

Neither are fantastic singers, but honestly, it's laughable people are trying to say Cheryl is better. Even if you personally prefer Cheryl's voice to Dannii's, Dannii is still the superior singer.

reminds me of the other thread where somebody was trying to convince us that singing in tune was a matter of "opinion"

Can't say I am terribly overwhelmed by either of them but, given the evidence you have all kindly provided, I would say that to my completely untrained and possibly tone deaf ear Dannii is the slightly stronger singer but Cheryl has the better song material.

I wouldn't buy much from either although I readily admit that I WOULD buy Parachute if I could but I refuse to pay import prices for it.

Dannii without a doubt, shes been in the west end and everything. Cheryl is a good dancer but she can't sing.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzBFRcuqJsE

Cheryls dancing is great.