dissolved_girl I love the collage, it's brilliant!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Really captured the different weeks brilliantly! Loves it!!
Re Cher - I fully respect everyone who likes her, everyone has different people who they relate to for different reasons and I think that's a good thing. For me though, I've never warmed to her, personality or performance wise. Don't get me wrong, I don't hate the girl or even dislike her.
I guess first off performance wise she's never cut it for me. If she had every week, taken a song and put her own spin on it with the rapping then fair play. I may not have liked it, but I could have accepted she was being her own individual artist. Instead for me every week she either did a song that already had rapping with it or did a ballad. She showed no sort of artistic individuality for me. I'm not entirely blaming her, I think Cheryl has to shoulder a lot of the blame.
Although I don't think she ever really successfully 'made a song her own' I didn't mind some of her performances. I thought something like 'Girlfriend' suited her. It was frivilous and young and think she is probably at her best when she was doing songs like that. I didn't like Stay, Imagine or Love the Way You Lie at all. I don't think she has the maturity or sincerity in her performances to even attempt songs of that depth. Again, not her fault, she shouldn't have been given the songs. To me it was like watching a little girl playing dress up. taking on those big songs made her seem younger than 17 to me.
I guess we don't really know what the contestants are like in terms of character and if they are disruptive at all. Although I believe there is an air of truth in Cher's, by what Brian Friedman said on the Xtra Factor the other day and also by the way Simon and Cheryl keep saying, 'we have to remember she's just 17'. That excuse doesn't buy it with me. when I was 17 I had jobs and responsibilities and I never went about being a little madam in any of them. Plus Aiden, Paige and 1Direction are all under 20 and they are as good as gold.
Anywho, just my opinion! I may be a little grouchy. I'm hungry. Even though I've just eaten. It's the cold weather, my body craves food all the time just in case I get snowed in again and have to survive off my body fat.