Based on how well they danced it:
Kara - 10
Matt - 10
Pamela - 8
Gavin - 8
Scott - 7

The reality is I vastly prefered Gavin and Scott's routines to Pamela's though. Where does James get this cringeworthy choreography?

1. Kara, by an absolute mile.

<huge gap>

2. Matt

3. Scott

4. Pamela (grossly overmarked, horrible choreography)

5. Gavin (though I would rather watch him than Pamela)