A yay from me, even though I never was a fan.
Take That this weekend - yay or nay?
1 of 2
going through the motions,they probably would rather be somewhere else with someone else,but they all know the clock is ticking and without the band they're nothing.that's a nay.
Yay from me! Nice to hear a band sing well live, instead of miming (not that I assume others mime on Strictly but just in general).
Originally Posted by warszawa:
“going through the motions,they probably would rather be somewhere else with someone else,but they all know the clock is ticking and without the band they're nothing.that's a nay.”
“going through the motions,they probably would rather be somewhere else with someone else,but they all know the clock is ticking and without the band they're nothing.that's a nay.”
All of their solo careers seem to have gone off the rails slightly, so I suppose you're right. They're doing what they can, while they still can.
I mentioned this on the results thread, but I don't think Robbie's mic was even on 
He kept pointing it at the audience instead of singing his bit (with his standard post-comeback dazed expression), and when he brought it back and sang into it there was no difference to the sound.
Otherwise, I thought it was a brilliant performance - Gary's as good as ever and it's a gorgeous song. The performance on X Factor on the other hand :S I blame Wand Erection, they are beyond poor. Can't even sing in unison, let alone harmony.
He kept pointing it at the audience instead of singing his bit (with his standard post-comeback dazed expression), and when he brought it back and sang into it there was no difference to the sound.
Otherwise, I thought it was a brilliant performance - Gary's as good as ever and it's a gorgeous song. The performance on X Factor on the other hand :S I blame Wand Erection, they are beyond poor. Can't even sing in unison, let alone harmony.
Originally Posted by Liparus:
“A yay from me, even though I never was a fan.”
“A yay from me, even though I never was a fan.”
No, nor was I, but I love Progress, it's a brilliant album. I didn't especially like Robbie solo either.. but I watched the documentary and it seems now like they're enjoying themselves, so why not?
So a big YAY! from me
BTW, how could they be on X Factor AT THE SAME TIME!!
<dramatic music>
Originally Posted by Herefordgirl:
“No, nor was I, but I love Progress, it's a brilliant album. I didn't especially like Robbie solo either.. but I watched the documentary and it seems now like they're enjoying themselves, so why not?
So a big YAY! from me
BTW, how could they be on X Factor AT THE SAME TIME!!
<dramatic music>”
“No, nor was I, but I love Progress, it's a brilliant album. I didn't especially like Robbie solo either.. but I watched the documentary and it seems now like they're enjoying themselves, so why not?
So a big YAY! from me
BTW, how could they be on X Factor AT THE SAME TIME!!
<dramatic music>”
Hologramic reproductions, a tribute band on X Factor - who knows thats the magic of television.
Definite yay from me.
At least on Strictly we didn't have to suffer the X Factor finalists as well just them on their own as it should be.
At least on Strictly we didn't have to suffer the X Factor finalists as well just them on their own as it should be.
1 of 2
