After watching the weird marking of the judges this season and agreeing with craig more times than I would want to admit it feels like time to have a shake up of the judging panel. I am a little tired of Len's jetlag, Bruno's hormones and Alisha's scoring based on who knows what .

Who would you like to see on the judging panel next year?

Karen Hardy seems a popular choice...any other ideas?

Karen without a doubt for me too, apart from her, perhaps Anton if he stops competing.

Craig plus 3 new judges.

Karen would be fabulous, failing that I'd settle for Camilla or Erin (both great judges on twitter every Saturday! )

If we're playing fantasy panel I'd go for Ian-Erin-Darren-Head Judge Bruno. Bruno only being Head Judge so he can use his power to make the other three wear fabulous costumes every week.

Bruno
Lilia
Matthew
and a hypnotised Craig who thinks it's still series 4.

Margaret Thatcher
Basil Brush
Lenin
Karen Hardy

She we have a reality TV contest to pick the new judges

Billy Connolly?

I'd have Craig, Bruno, Karen and Matt Cutler. Or Ian Waite. Anton maybe then I'd see him every week and never have to cringe at his celeb ever again like this year but I'd prefer to keep him dancing

Love it!

Keep Craig and add Erin, Ian and Karen. The other three judges seem far too subjective with their marks. Anton could present the show if he doesn't have Erin to dance with. I hate all the vitriol directed at Bruce, especially as he is genuinely passionate about dance, but I do feel slightly embarrassed for him as he clearly has trouble presenting a live show these days.

Louis Spence

I love Ian and have missed him on the program this year so would love to see him as a judge.

<...applause!>

Craig, Len, Erin and Brendan.

Not going to happen.

Dame Edna (unparalleled waspishness)
Arsene Wenger (because he never sees anything wrong)
David Blunkett (ditto)
Matt Cutler (selfish - just so I can gaze on him again)

Len, Craig, Erin, Bruno or swap Len for Ian...I like Bruno, he goes off on a rant when he's excited...which is all the time!

Craig
Ian
Karen
Bruno

Interesting choices but would substitute Miss Piggy for one of them, she knows all about performance dahling, Lenin might be a bit - well - past his sell by date, but Kermit might make for some interesting discussion, especially if Bruno was by his side, applaud your choice of Karen, maybe Winehouse would honour us with his presence once again.

Oooh, just read through the other posts, am liking Dame Edna, bye Kermie.

David Blunkett
Andy Fordham
Jo Brand
John McCririck

Couldn't be any more random than the current state of play.

The three men as before. And a person who is not Ms Dixon.

Me! Me!

<.... bounces up and down with her hand in the air>

Karen Hardy would be amazing on the panel. I actually agree with Craig a lot of the time. Not sure I should admit that, but hey!

Craig
Karen
Erin
Ian

People seem to like Karen, I would go with that too! There is also Camilla as well .., and didn't she publicly say she'd like to be a judge after stepping down from her Pro role on the show? Wonder why the Beeb never chose Karen or Camilla instead of Alesha.

My HM mentioned Shirely Ballas but I don't know if her schedule in America would permit it or even if she'd want to be a judge on Strictly. I remember she had done a group dance for Strictly once.