Your choice of judges for next year...?

2 of 2

Tall Paul

13-12-2010

Originally Posted by Miriam_R:
“People seem to like Karen, I would go with that too! There is also Camilla as well .., and didn't she publicly say she'd like to be a judge after stepping down from her Pro role on the show? Wonder why the Beeb never chose Karen or Camilla instead of Alesha.

My HM mentioned Shirely Ballas but I don't know if her schedule in America would permit it or even if she'd want to be a judge on Strictly. I remember she had done a group dance for Strictly once.”

bbc ought to have more faith in her rather than going for tried and trusted lol.

jammy36

13-12-2010

Originally Posted by Chrissi_1986:
“Karen Hardy would be amazing on the panel. I actually agree with Craig a lot of the time. Not sure I should admit that, but hey!”

Not weird when you consider the marking supplied by the other judges!

SideshowStu

13-12-2010

If we're stuck with the props and the faffing again next year I'd like to see the following on the panel...

The Krankies
The 'Go compare' singer
Ant and/or Dec

The reason being that I have a violent aversion to them all and it would give me another excuse not to bother with the show at all

However, if by a miracle the faffing abaht is knocked on the head and the judges get a recognisable routine to criticize, I'd like to see...

Craig
Karen
Camilla
Brendan...or Darren...or anyone else who knows what they're talking about and can say it without resorting to pantomime

Tall Paul

13-12-2010

Originally Posted by jammy36:
“Not weird when you consider the marking supplied by the other judges! ”

the marking from the other judges is ridiculous.

Tall Paul

13-12-2010

Forgot to add bbc should get their ceo on here asap(fingers crossed).

jammy36

13-12-2010

Am smiling at the idea of the go compare man!

He could make even more noise than bruno...

Tall Paul

13-12-2010

Originally Posted by jammy36:
“Am smiling at the idea of the go compare man!
He could make even more noise than bruno...”

like I said before bbc focus who can do the best business for them rather than paying attention to the viewers.

Osusana

13-12-2010

I'm amazed at all the posts supporting Karen Hardy - I find her rictus grin truly off putting and hated the way she danced (almost an exaggeration of being a pro dancer)
I suppose if she is judging - we don't have to see her on the dance floor.

Swimming against the tide but I really like Craig, Len and Bruno!

Tall Paul

13-12-2010

Originally Posted by Osusana:
“I'm amazed at all the posts supporting Karen Hardy - I find her rictus grin truly off putting and hated the way she danced (almost an exaggeration of being a pro dancer)
I suppose if she is judging - we don't have to see her on the dance floor.

Swimming against the tide but I really like Craig, Len and Bruno!”

it's time for change imho.

jammy36

13-12-2010

I used to feel the same, keep swimming against the tide away!

This year I have wondered what they've seen that I haven't. Some people have been unable to put a foot wrong and others never managing to do enough. I wish the judges would be a bit more consistent to all the contestants. (The ranting at the TV every week is beginning to take it's toll - I spotted grey hairs in my fringe this morning!)

2 of 2