Originally Posted by Andy23:
“You are joking? It's BBC1 who sometimes show crap and get good ratings.
There have been numerous shows flagged on here that are of poor quality, yet rate very well. CFWM was slated, The Magicians, the other day they showed a daytime show followed by an ancient film which rated well also.
Then of course there is the BBC daytime schedule, where Weakest Link still rates well, 100 years after it started!”
The pilot of CFWM was weak, but luckily it started late on Christmas Day when most would be too merry at that point to really notice. It's picked up since then and viewers seem to be liking it more. I expect a recommission within days.
The Magicians was poor but has been fortunate in being scheduled opposite Primeval, a previously cancelled drama that has struggled to make any impact at all since it came back. Even you yourself admitted it had got "lost" in the schedules and two episodes in one weekend was clearly too much. I wouldn't put the apparent ratings success of The Magicians down to anything other than that.
As for Indiana, it might have been old but it's also a classic. I don't really see it that differently to ITV's obsession with James Bond and Harry Potter. At least the BBC are giving us a much needed break from POTC.
The Weakest Link doesn't really rate that great to be honest, so I don't buy that one. It regularly loses its timeslot to C4 and sometimes even BBC Two when there are new episodes of Escape To The Country on.