how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.
judges favoring Kara
1 of 2
started a thread similar.
they told matt not enough dancing in it, but not Kara.
they told matt it was stop start but not kara.
it stinks
they told matt not enough dancing in it, but not Kara.
they told matt it was stop start but not kara.
it stinks
All 3 showdances were bloody awful for a variety of reasons.
Is it really worth debating which was the crappiest?
Is it really worth debating which was the crappiest?
Why do you keep attacking Kara? I agree that Matt was underscored but why attack another contestant to make your point?
Originally Posted by crispih:
“how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.”
“how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.”
Quite easily. Matt had a routine made up of random pointless gymnastics moves and still had errors and timing mistakes. Kara had a properly choregraphed dance routine with more dancing more content and more difficulty and made errors and over ran a bit. He gets 7 for a mess that could never get a 10 even if performed perfectly . She gets 9 for a routine thats stuffed with too much difficulty for even a 10 routine, but which was performed with errors. You do the right sort of routine and you make errors trying for too much difficulty and you get rewarded for it.
Pamela's mark from Craig made sense too. There wasn't anything new or that difficult there, but it flowed and looked like a standard dance. She made fewest errors doing it, but she has to lose 1 when the difficulty level wasn't high anyway.
Its pretty much impossible to mark much better than that with 3 widely different dances and 3 lots of questionable, over ambitious or safe choregraphy. Even if they had 3 better choreographers, there's probably not much time to do better when you have too much to do this week.
Originally Posted by drbolognaise:
“Errm, Kara is not top of the board...the judges favour Pamela
”
“Errm, Kara is not top of the board...the judges favour Pamela
”
To be fair, Pamela's showdance was much better than Kara's
Originally Posted by Xassy:
“Why do you keep attacking Kara? I agree that Matt was underscored but why attack another contestant to make your point?”
“Why do you keep attacking Kara? I agree that Matt was underscored but why attack another contestant to make your point?”
because I don;'t like her -
Originally Posted by thenetworkbabe:
“Quite easily. Matt had a routine made up of random pointless gymnastics moves and still had errors and timing mistakes. Kara had a properly choregraphed dance routine with more dancing more content and more difficulty and made errors and over ran a bit. He gets 7 for a mess that could never get a 10 even if performed perfectly . She gets 9 for a routine thats stuffed with too much difficulty for even a 10 routine, but which was performed with errors. You do the right sort of routine and you make errors trying for too much difficulty and you get rewarded for it.
Pamela's mark from Craig made sense too. There wasn't anything new or that difficult there, but it flowed and looked like a standard dance. She made fewest errors doing it, but she has to lose 1 when the difficulty level wasn't high anyway.
Its pretty much impossible to mark much better than that with 3 widely different dances and 3 lots of questionable, over ambitious or safe choregraphy. Even if they had 3 better choreographers, there's probably not much time to do better when you have too much to do this week.”
“Quite easily. Matt had a routine made up of random pointless gymnastics moves and still had errors and timing mistakes. Kara had a properly choregraphed dance routine with more dancing more content and more difficulty and made errors and over ran a bit. He gets 7 for a mess that could never get a 10 even if performed perfectly . She gets 9 for a routine thats stuffed with too much difficulty for even a 10 routine, but which was performed with errors. You do the right sort of routine and you make errors trying for too much difficulty and you get rewarded for it.
Pamela's mark from Craig made sense too. There wasn't anything new or that difficult there, but it flowed and looked like a standard dance. She made fewest errors doing it, but she has to lose 1 when the difficulty level wasn't high anyway.
Its pretty much impossible to mark much better than that with 3 widely different dances and 3 lots of questionable, over ambitious or safe choregraphy. Even if they had 3 better choreographers, there's probably not much time to do better when you have too much to do this week.”
mats routine was not a mess - it was not to the judges liking - they are against him
What a surprise! Kara overmarked as usual!!!!
In her earlier VT I thought she'd never manage to make her eyes water, so many attempts to get emotional without her voice even breaking. And then sucess! Finally her eyes produced some liquid! At least all that that effort (and stage school) finally got its reward!
In her earlier VT I thought she'd never manage to make her eyes water, so many attempts to get emotional without her voice even breaking. And then sucess! Finally her eyes produced some liquid! At least all that that effort (and stage school) finally got its reward!
Originally Posted by dragonrat:
“Apparently, Kara injured her arm doing her show dance.
(”
“Apparently, Kara injured her arm doing her show dance.
(”
on injury each plus hints of really liking each other, she left out the granny and how she was imspired by someone deceased
Originally Posted by crispih:
“how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.”
“how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.”
Because Kara had more up tempo dancing and put so much into it. If the judges are favouring anybody then it is Pamela not Kara!
I was not impressed with Matts own dance with the cap on at all!
Originally Posted by crispih:
“how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.”
“how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.”
In your opinion of course.
Originally Posted by dragonrat:
“Apparently, Kara injured her arm doing her show dance.(”
“Apparently, Kara injured her arm doing her show dance.
(”
Yes, I thought so, hope that it does not hamper her with the next two dances if she gets through!
Rubbish... The whole thing is set up for Pamela to win.
Putting her on last, which is always an advantage.
But I'm voting for the girl who's been a class above anyone I've ever seen on this show... Kara.
Putting her on last, which is always an advantage.
But I'm voting for the girl who's been a class above anyone I've ever seen on this show... Kara.
Not from where I'm sitting. Pamela is the one being favoured. Kara got given the kiss of death by one of Brucie's poor jokes.
Originally Posted by GetMeOuttaHere:
“Not from where I'm sitting. Pamela is being favoured. Kara got given the kiss of death by one of Brucie's poor jokes.”
“Not from where I'm sitting. Pamela is being favoured. Kara got given the kiss of death by one of Brucie's poor jokes.”
I said the very same ,
Originally Posted by thenetworkbabe:
“Quite easily. Matt had a routine made up of random pointless gymnastics moves and still had errors and timing mistakes. Kara had a properly choregraphed dance routine with more dancing more content and more difficulty and made errors and over ran a bit. He gets 7 for a mess that could never get a 10 even if performed perfectly . She gets 9 for a routine thats stuffed with too much difficulty for even a 10 routine, but which was performed with errors. You do the right sort of routine and you make errors trying for too much difficulty and you get rewarded for it.
Pamela's mark from Craig made sense too. There wasn't anything new or that difficult there, but it flowed and looked like a standard dance. She made fewest errors doing it, but she has to lose 1 when the difficulty level wasn't high anyway.
Its pretty much impossible to mark much better than that with 3 widely different dances and 3 lots of questionable, over ambitious or safe choregraphy. Even if they had 3 better choreographers, there's probably not much time to do better when you have too much to do this week.”
“Quite easily. Matt had a routine made up of random pointless gymnastics moves and still had errors and timing mistakes. Kara had a properly choregraphed dance routine with more dancing more content and more difficulty and made errors and over ran a bit. He gets 7 for a mess that could never get a 10 even if performed perfectly . She gets 9 for a routine thats stuffed with too much difficulty for even a 10 routine, but which was performed with errors. You do the right sort of routine and you make errors trying for too much difficulty and you get rewarded for it.
Pamela's mark from Craig made sense too. There wasn't anything new or that difficult there, but it flowed and looked like a standard dance. She made fewest errors doing it, but she has to lose 1 when the difficulty level wasn't high anyway.
Its pretty much impossible to mark much better than that with 3 widely different dances and 3 lots of questionable, over ambitious or safe choregraphy. Even if they had 3 better choreographers, there's probably not much time to do better when you have too much to do this week.”
Kara definitely had more content and was more up temp with lots of dance moves. I thought that Pamelas was so samey and boring! They definitely played it safe. It really is so obvious that the judges want James to win this year because he has been with them for so long and does not want Artem or the red haired lady to win!
Originally Posted by crispih:
“on injury each plus hints of really liking each other, she left out the granny and how she was imspired by someone deceased”
“on injury each plus hints of really liking each other, she left out the granny and how she was imspired by someone deceased”
May I hazard a guess that you don't like Kara very much?
Originally Posted by crispih:
“mats routine was not a mess - it was not to the judges liking - they are against him”
“mats routine was not a mess - it was not to the judges liking - they are against him”
It was a mess, sorry but it was. Kara's wasn't very good either but it pipped Matt's to the post.
Originally Posted by BillyBoy7:
“Rubbish... The whole thing is set up for Pamela to win.
Putting her on last, which is always an advantage.
But I'm voting for the girl who's been a class above anyone I've ever seen on this show... Kara.”
“Rubbish... The whole thing is set up for Pamela to win.
Putting her on last, which is always an advantage.
But I'm voting for the girl who's been a class above anyone I've ever seen on this show... Kara.”
Yes, totally agree, and I have voted over 20 times for Kara already and if she is in the final two I will vote more. She is easily the best all round dancer this year!
Not only is Kara a class above all the others, I also agree that she is probably the best we have had on the show and the passion and charisma that she has with Artem is totally amazing. They are on fire!
Originally Posted by crispih:
“how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.”
“how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.”
:yawn: :yawn: :yawn:
Originally Posted by crispih:
“how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.”
“how can craig and the judges say Kara's dance was as good as mats - she was weak on tumbles and forgot which way she was going at the end.”
It isn't a tumbling competition, its a dancing competition. Kara's was more difficult than Matt's and had more dance content. Even despite errors it was better than Matt's (which I thought was awful)
Originally Posted by Caro07:
“What a surprise! Kara overmarked as usual!!!!
In her earlier VT I thought she'd never manage to make her eyes water, so many attempts to get emotional without her voice even breaking. And then sucess! Finally her eyes produced some liquid! At least all that that effort (and stage school) finally got its reward!”
“What a surprise! Kara overmarked as usual!!!!
In her earlier VT I thought she'd never manage to make her eyes water, so many attempts to get emotional without her voice even breaking. And then sucess! Finally her eyes produced some liquid! At least all that that effort (and stage school) finally got its reward!”
I'm totally fed up with the poisonous digs you never miss a chance to aim at Kara, so I'm going to have to admit defeat and put you on ignore.
1 of 2
