Poll please

Robin
Emma
Jason

Best Judge?

Robin and Jason outshine Emma by far, they offer constructive advice and actually comment on the skating and performance compared with Emmas 'Ive a soft spot for you' or 'I like your smile.' WTF EMMA?

Robin, At least he knows what he's talking about.

Robin.

Robin

Robin.

Robin. He always has been.

Robin, though Jason was pretty constructive tonight.
Emma is dreadful.

Robin

I can't believe they axe Karen but keep Emma. It's ridiculous they have only 1 judge who knows about skating.


If Emma's a trained judge in performance because she's performed in one of the biggest girl bands then surely that means some of the contestants could be judges Angela already has, Kerry Katona was in a girlband as well and Vanilla Ice is a singer so surely they are just as qualified as Emma aren't they?

Anyone gonna vote for Jason or Emma PMSL. Certainly not me - Robin all the way.

Robin, the only one really qualified to comment...and please bring Karen Barber back...and Katerina Witt would be a great hire! AND PLEASE GET RID OF BUNTON

robin. he was the only one marking actually decent tonight. jason kept giving two's and i dont even take notice of what emma does !

Robin. Should have got rid of Jason in my opinion, ridiculous marking tonight. If he gave 2/10, what would he have given using last year's scores? 0?

And why axe Karen, move her 2 foot and still ask her opinion! Give the woman a paddle so she can score!

Robin - at least he has actually skated. And he's very constructive with his comments.

Robin

What a pointless thread. It's obviously Robin cos he's the only one who knows anything about skating LOL

Robin. WTF are the other 2 doing on there. The shows becoming totally pointless and annoying.

Robin.
He's the only one allowed to have an opinion as he is the only one that knows what he is talking about.

Robin.

Robin without a doubt!

Robin only skater thats judging , bring back Nicky and Get rid of useless Emma Bunting.

Out of those three, it's clearly Robin.

Jason annoys me, because he's often just mean for the sake of it, he could be constructive instead but he makes these horrible insulting comparisons. Craig (usually) gets away with it on SCD because he is at least quite charming and warm, but Jason hasn't got any of that natural warmth or charisma so it just comes across as rude.

Robin.

Robin.

(and yeah, I agree with the others, get rid of Emma)

Robin

Robin