Originally Posted by sn_22:
“Well absolutely - soaps are an entirely different beast in the US, as is their TV landscape in general (most notably, far far more competition). Daytime soaps there are hilariously glossy, weird, fantastical things - and are dying by the year.
I'm sure if any sort of down-to-earth misery-fest had a chance in primetime, a desperate executive would have tried it by now! We were just remarking that US networks would love to have such regular, successful, cheap staples as ITV and BBC enjoy here. They do, after all, have many more daily year-round shows out of primetime (daytime talk, late night comedy. etc) but not within primetime.”
It has been tried - not actually on TV, but in development.
Mal Young, who created or co-created Family Affairs, Doctors, Holby City and served as Controller of Continuing Drama at the BBC, joined 19 TV (Simon Fuller's company) as Head of Drama.
They had a couple of cracks at shows set on the same street focussing on 3 blue collar families. One involved Tony Jordan in 2005 but never got past the script stage. Then Fuller/Young tried again in 2007, got a pilot but no series order.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2004...s.broadcasting
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/4020589.stm
http://casino.thesun.co.uk/sol/homep...s-planned.html
It just wouldn't work, though. Aside from the nature of the show, its scheduling and format just doesn't work with US primetime TV. Even Big Brother doesn't get 4 nights a week over there.
Univision (Spanish language network) does have soaps in primetimes (or telenovas) and does well with them. In the summer they sometimes beat the English language channels in the demo.