Yes, I agree, she was made to look rather old, but I loved the dress, it was so elegant!

You do have more reasons why you think it shouldn't be at the bottom, right?

Of course, she sang it beautifully, she had the best entrance to a performance in an ALW show of all time, its probably the nicest song to just listen to without watching it!

Well I am pleased to hear we have sober mafiosi as well as drunken ones. I will be entering the ranks of the lushes in Feb.

Isn't a bit extreme to say best of all time. it was a good entrance, but there have been better once out there. It's definitely the bridge performance between the poor first 3, with one exception, week to the superior weeks 5 till 8.

No not really, because it was the best entrance ever on one of those shows. If you can name a better one, go ahead??

You never said shows. You said of all time. The entrances of the performances were never anything special, so this one doesn't have any rivals.

*SNAP* You're the first one!

Agree with both! My Sister's Keeper is one of the most beautiful films I've ever seen! You should know it! (the film, not what I thought of it! XD)
And yeah, Cry me a River should not be at the bottom!!! It was amazing!

oo no! I'll be honest I think it made her look fat! and she's not fat. I just feel the dress did nothing for her body. Every time I watch that performance i cringe. I'm doing that week for the fan book ironically so I'm going to have to be nice.

the first 3 performances were not poor! She just got better. I loved her performances of just a little girl and red!

it is a beautiful film. It's easy to cry through the whole thing. The book is better though! The film did a stupid ending. That's not what Jodi Picoult is about.

Sorry cry me a river was not a fav and it never will be

I haven't read the book, so I don't know what's the difference.
Actually I watched it cause Stephanie mentioned it a million times, and I wanted to know why she (and everybody else) says it's so good.

It's just my opinion. I didn't think she stood out then.

I don't think anyone is in an agreeable mood today, everyone seems to contradict each other.

Except Rebeka, at least you agree with me that Cry me a river is a decent performance.

Haha, yeah! AGREE!!! XD

I'm sorry, I've never heard of it at all.

Exactly.

haha. Use your mind powers, agree AGREE AGREE

Though I didn't really liked the dress (it looked like a curtain ), but her hair was sooo good! I loved it! But she did the whole number beatuifully!

Don't get me wrong i think it is a good performance that i enjoy to watch.

Well, it would be a bit dull if we agreed with each other all the time!

Lol, I just watched it on youtube! And was singing it yesterday. (like all day! )

Yes Sonny, I completely agree with everything you say

So does this curtain of yours come with a Danielle Hope as a bonus, wrapped in the curtain???

I had Red in my head all day Friday. And yesterday i had Get Happy in my head.

Haha! Tho it would be quite nicer to have the 18-year-old Danielle instead of the 18-year-old alcoholist brother! XD Dan would make a great sister of mine!

haa, poor brother, wished away for Danielle. *think happy thoughts Rebeka*!