At least Louie is a top dancer and choreographer, and would merit his place on the panel, and hopefully would not be as nasty as Jason who I think overstepped the mark tonight. Jason can have good points but does not need to go overboard like this.

I agree, he would be so much more entertaining than Jason!

Fab idea! I'm worried he may be too busy though, but he would be great!

Me and my mum were just saying this earlier! I would love it if he replaced Jason.

He'd be the same as Jason and not really have any credentials to be a judge but he'd be so much better!

Aw, get away with you! He'd be great! Anyway, he has great credentials as a dancer, since this is dancing on ice. He also has better dress sense!

I bet we're all watching "That Sunday Night Show"

Well he would be great is what I was trying to say! But to be honest, most people would be better than JG!

ohhh good idea but replacing emma

I can't stand the man, the silly camp as a row of tents act he puts on gets on my wick. He loves to show off to much to be able sit on a judging panel!

Cheers Diva Moon my thoughts entirely, I am sure Louie would add a little sunshine too our Sunday evenings.

He has exactly the same credentials as Jason then, as he was most famous for being a dancer and choreographer before doing Dancing on Ice, which is probably why they are already good friends.

The main difference is that Jason has many years experience of working on an Ice Dancing show, and knows enough about skating not to ignore it (like Ruthie used to do).

Guilty as charged !!
But he would make a great judge with his knowlege of dancing & I'm sure he wouldn't be as offensive as Jason & he doesn't wear aggravating hats

Had no idea Louie was on tonight, pity I missed him

Yes and his shirts are much more tasteful and he is generally more entertaining. Some camp guys really get on my nerves (such as Graham Norton) but Louis is just one big ball of entertainment. He has grown on me like a wart.

someone needs to come in that can compliment Emma's high skills. One of the wombles maybe.

Loving this, yep that's Louie we feel exactly the same in this household. But I myself am a dancer, and boy can that man dance.

Yes she's aggravating too, get shot of her - when was she a dancer/skater
Jason needs to go though he's gone too far this time
He is just plain nasty
How about Robin, Louis & perhaps a previous winner at least he or she would know a bit about it

Yes guest Judges would be great any ideas ?

Now there's a thought Uncle Bulgaria on the judges desk
At least he'd look better than tombstone toothed Jason in his daft hat

I had to revive this

Amazing! How often does that happen. I thought Louie did a great job, he's a natural as a judge and got bags of charisma. Way more likeable than Jason, although not afraid to speak his mind.