• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • Entertainment
  • Books, Newspapers & Comics
Superman V's Wolverine
<<
<
2 of 3
>>
>
Seaborn
07-05-2011
Wow.

OK, I'm a huge comic book fan, and have been since I could understand the basic shapes that made up the drawing of a human. Even before i could read, loved comics and the characters.

So please believe me when I say that this isn't even a fight. Superman annihilates Wolverine in 0.0000000009 of a second.

Wolverine isn't that much faster or stronger than your average human. Superman is splitting moons in half and travelling at or around lightspeed.

Some scale - the speed of thought is about the speed of sound, roughly. Superman, moving at or around lightspeed, is literally thousands of times faster than even Wolverine's thoughts. That means that before Wolverine has had the thought "I should pop my claws" he's been thrown into space where he'll float about forever, or in the sun, where he'd be incinerated to the point of no return.

The Marvel Vs DC comic people are referring to was decided by fans, not writers, so the results where essentially a popularity contest. Hence Wolverine taking Lobo, Storm beating Wonder Woman (similar reaction/strength defecit as Superman and Wolverine) and other such things.

I promise, guys, straight up fight and Wolverine is a small pile of dust and adamantium shavings.
superboy
07-05-2011
yes my older self would obliterate wolvereine
Seaborn
07-05-2011
Originally Posted by superboy:
“yes my older self would obliterate wolvereine”

As would you! Connor Kent is still considerably faster and stronger than Wolverine could hope to be. Add in the tactike TK and Wolverine dies. Again.
PinSarla
07-05-2011
As other people have said wolverine could win with kryptonite weapons, or perhaps kryptonite coated claws. I guess he could find someone clever enough to make these kryptonite coated claws/ weapons. Then if he could get the drop on Superman first.....but if Superman was to face off against him?

Wolverine would go down like a sack of sh!t, not that that would be my preffered outcome in this fictional world of mine
Kablamo
07-05-2011
Originally Posted by Seaborn:
“Wow.

OK, I'm a huge comic book fan, and have been since I could understand the basic shapes that made up the drawing of a human. Even before i could read, loved comics and the characters.

So please believe me when I say that this isn't even a fight. Superman annihilates Wolverine in 0.0000000009 of a second.

Wolverine isn't that much faster or stronger than your average human. Superman is splitting moons in half and travelling at or around lightspeed.

Some scale - the speed of thought is about the speed of sound, roughly. Superman, moving at or around lightspeed, is literally thousands of times faster than even Wolverine's thoughts. That means that before Wolverine has had the thought "I should pop my claws" he's been thrown into space where he'll float about forever, or in the sun, where he'd be incinerated to the point of no return.

The Marvel Vs DC comic people are referring to was decided by fans, not writers, so the results where essentially a popularity contest. Hence Wolverine taking Lobo, Storm beating Wonder Woman (similar reaction/strength defecit as Superman and Wolverine) and other such things.

I promise, guys, straight up fight and Wolverine is a small pile of dust and adamantium shavings.”

It will depend upon how the fight is started and where the first blow is laid. Adamantium is a pretty strong substance so I'm unsure how Superman will cope with this.
Seaborn
07-05-2011
Originally Posted by Kablamo:
“It will depend upon how the fight is started and where the first blow is laid. Adamantium is a pretty strong substance so I'm unsure how Superman will cope with this.”

The strength of adamantium is irrelevant. Wolverine does not posses the physical strength to push the adamantium hard enough to pierce Superman's skin. Bullets can't pierce his skin, a punch from Wolverine certainly wouldn't. It's not a matter of the strength of material - although that would play into it if Wolvie were strong enough - or even how sharp the claws are, Wolverine simply cant supply enough force to break the skin of a guy who can walk through nukes.
Ultra Magnus
04-06-2011
Originally Posted by Seaborn:
“Wow.

OK, I'm a huge comic book fan, and have been since I could understand the basic shapes that made up the drawing of a human. Even before i could read, loved comics and the characters.

So please believe me when I say that this isn't even a fight. Superman annihilates Wolverine in 0.0000000009 of a second.”

Thing is, it's established that Batman can defeat Superman.

Whilst Bruce Wayne is probably smarter than Logan, he doesn't have the heightened senses, strength, indestructable skeleton or willingness to kill.

If a powerless playboy can take down Supes, so can Wolverine.
nathanbrazil
06-06-2011
Originally Posted by Brigon:
“SIf you want a closer match up between Marvel and DC, pit Superman against Hulk, Thor or Sentry”

No need. Posters seem to be forgetting that Superman has another weakness; magic. As magic definitely exists in the Marvel universe, all Wolverine needs to do is get himself tooled up - enchanted claws, or something - via any one of the magic practitioners. Then in the DC universe, stand behind Shazam... until he's close enough, then none of Superman's powers would matter.
nathanbrazil
06-06-2011
Originally Posted by Seaborn:
“Wolverine simply cant supply enough force to break the skin of a guy who can walk through nukes.”

Again, if the claws are enchanted, then penetrating Superman's skin would be as easy as cutting through any other substance.
whip
06-06-2011
Originally Posted by Ultra Magnus:
“Thing is, it's established that Batman can defeat Superman.

Whilst Bruce Wayne is probably smarter than Logan, he doesn't have the heightened senses, strength, indestructable skeleton or willingness to kill.

If a powerless playboy can take down Supes, so can Wolverine.”

That's what people are forgetting Superman's moral code, he wouldn't throw wolverine into the sun or any other morally objectionable way to kill him.
While Superman would be trying to persuade wolvy on the error of his ways wolverine would be decapitating supes with kryptonite/magic laced claws.
Seaborn
06-06-2011
Originally Posted by nathanbrazil:
“Again, if the claws are enchanted, then penetrating Superman's skin would be as easy as cutting through any other substance.”

Oh cool, i didn't realise calling in your allies was allowed.

In which case, Superman calls up the Phantom Stranger, who enchants him to be immune to magic. Phantom Stranger did this at the end of Kurt Buseik's Camelot Falls arc, so there is precedent for it happening in the comics. Now the enchanted claws don't matter.

Seriously, your answer to Superman Vs Wolverine was "Well, if we say that before it wolverine goes and gets one of his mates to give him Superman's weakness, THEN he could win!" Give ME magic claws and I'd stand a fighting chance.

Wolverine isn't anywhere near Superman's weight class. And for the record, even if the claws were enchanted, Superman is literally about a million times faster than Logan. Logan is defeated faster than the thought that tells his claws to pop has crossed from one side of his brain to the other.
Seaborn
06-06-2011
Originally Posted by Ultra Magnus:
“Thing is, it's established that Batman can defeat Superman.

Whilst Bruce Wayne is probably smarter than Logan, he doesn't have the heightened senses, strength, indestructable skeleton or willingness to kill.

If a powerless playboy can take down Supes, so can Wolverine.”

In all Superman/Batman fights, batman has had two things going for him - Kryptonite and Superman holding back. The fight in the Hush, Bruce's internal monologue reads "Clark is holding back, if he weren't i'd be crushed into the sidewalk."

Dark Knight Returns, Bruce had to hit him with a nuke, then body armour powered by the city and had Green Arrow firing Kryptonite arrows from the roof.

Wolverine has none of this. And I say again - Wolverine is so slow compared to Superman's galaxy-crossing speeds that the fight is over before the sound of the bell ringing has reached Wolverine's ears.
whip
06-06-2011
Originally Posted by Seaborn:
“Wolverine is so slow compared to Superman's galaxy-crossing speeds that the fight is over before the sound of the bell ringing has reached Wolverine's ears.”

You could say that about 90% of superman's villains but it has been shown time and time again superman is too dimwitted to use his powers effectively.
Superbeast
07-06-2011
Superman picks him up, flies him into the void of outer space and Wolverine implodes.

End of fight.
whip
07-06-2011
Originally Posted by Superbeast:
“Superman picks him up, flies him into the void of outer space and Wolverine implodes.

End of fight.”

Apart from the fact Superman wouldn't do that, if he would Lex Luthor would be long gone.
Oxus
11-06-2011
The reality is they would be allies : Batman only fought him as a last resort and still didnt really eliminate Superman .. because they are on the same side. Wolverine would have to have a really good reason to kill superman and he really doesnt.

..But imagine a wolverine with light speed and nuclear magic krypton blades vs. first appearance Superman!
Mrs Teapot
12-06-2011
Originally Posted by Oxus:
“The reality is they would be allies : Batman only fought him as a last resort and still didnt really eliminate Superman .. because they are on the same side. Wolverine would have to have a really good reason to kill superman and he really doesnt.

..But imagine a wolverine with light speed and nuclear magic krypton blades vs. first appearance Superman!”

The reality is that Wolverine has an Adaminium skeleton and Superman has developed a resistance against Kryptonite.
not_the_doctor
12-06-2011
Originally Posted by Mrs Teapot:
“The reality is that Wolverine has an Adaminium skeleton and Superman has developed a resistance against Kryptonite.”

Actually, the reality is that these are fictional characters, and that very little reality is involved at all.

As for these pointless superhero vs superhero threads, the simple answer is that Superman wins every time. Winning a battle doesn't have to result in death. There are more ways than I could be bothered to count for Superman to incapacitate and neutralize Wolverine.
Mrs Teapot
12-06-2011
Originally Posted by not_the_doctor:
“Actually, the reality is that these are fictional characters, and that very little reality is involved at all.

As for these pointless superhero vs superhero threads, the simple answer is that Superman wins every time. Winning a battle doesn't have to result in death. There are more ways than I could be bothered to count for Superman to incapacitate and neutralize Wolverine.”

I know but imagination is a good thing but I don't want anyone to die.

I cannot imagine Superman winning over The Silver Surfer or The Vision

Superman and Spiderman did battle though in a comic released in 1976
Oxus
13-06-2011
If it were my story. ..Action Comics #1 Superman vs Weapon X during the early American alcohol prohibition along the Canadian border. Throw The Hulk in there to even them out if you think they need it.
andrewmac1
13-06-2011
super man
Superbeast
13-06-2011
Originally Posted by whip:
“Apart from the fact Superman wouldn't do that, if he would Lex Luthor would be long gone.”

Lex Luthor is a human being.

Wolverine is a mutant who can heal himself time and time again.

Also Superman has killed before when faced with threats he knew would come back and threaten humanity. He killed Doomsday, he finished off Darkseid... so him dumping a guy who has killed thousands in space who he knows will keep healing is not above Superman.
Yuffie
19-06-2011
God thread, makes for a great read ....

I'd have to go with Superman ... It does all depend on circumstances, why and where they are fighting ...

But if this is just a fight to the death for the craic, then Wolverine doesn't stand a chance, Superman could kill him in a million different ways ... It wouldn't even be worth going to see ... kryptonite or no kryptonite ...

If theres actually a genuine reason for this fight, and we're taking morals and everything else into account, then maybe wolverine could outsmart him in some way but I doubt it ...
Quickblood
20-06-2011
In theory anyone can beat Superman if they can get the Kryptonite but really Superman Vs Wolvierine is way too one sided. Even a particularly weak written Superman would surely just kill Wolverine and toss his remains into the sun before he could regenerate.
Baffrobes
27-06-2011
Loving this thread, takes me back.

Couldn't Superman just keep his distance and either Freeze and shatter, or heatray and melt Wolverene?
Then throw the bits into space.
Or turn back time and Kill logan before the Adamantine was ever injected!
Only one winner in this showdown.
<<
<
2 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map