Had a watch of this a few weeks back. I agree with the others, it is a pretty faithful adaptation of a decent but not amazing story. It's not quite up there with GL First Flight or Superman Doomsday, or even New Frontier or WW, but it's definitely worth a watch.
Originally Posted by not_the_doctor:
“Another problem is that nobody seems to write Superman as a likable or charismatic character anymore. It feels like too many writers have gotten too wrapped up in the demi-god/Jesus characterisation.”
I think JMS had been hoping to fix that with the on-going Grounded arc, but sadly it's just a boring mess! I believe he's no longer working on it, though, and is now doing a follow up to Superman Earth One, so perhaps there's hope! I haven't actually read Superman Earth One, so I don't know if that does a good job of humanising Supes. (Obviously I'm aware that it's an alternate Earth Supes, but all the same...)