I just don't understand it at all.

What does she know about this? She's some random lucky individual who joined a girl band that was orchestrated by a shrewd business man.

We lost some really talented judges for her? Her comments just come across as MEH. It's shocking that these celebs and even the random nobodies who are skating have these agents that force their clients in our faces.

I was wondering how she came to be a judge. Has she been on DOI as a contestant? At least Alesha Dixon had taken part in the show, SCD.

No idea. When that stroppy camp judge ( I don't know their names ) mocked that judge from last year about not having comments I thought, say the same to Emma!!

Weird.

We seem to keep asking the same Question about Emma week after week and it won't make any differance to the outcome(s), and yes i agree what is she doing a judge

She was particularly useless tonight.

What do you mean tonight, it every week shes useless just not tonight

Somebody somewhere thinks we want to see a spice girl every week and that somebody somewhere is very wrong.

She said nothing at all of any significance tonight. Some nights she says something, maybe a tiny morsel; but tonight it was like nothing.

She's about as much use as a judge as her bandmate Cheryl on xf - ie useless.

Her bandmate?

In Cheryl's defence, at least she is related to the music industry and she would know something about it. The fact that she can't sing doesn't help, but still.

Emma is not a dance expert and she knows nothing about skating.

She is there to look pretty

She's isn't uber attractive but she looks ok.

If I wanted someone there to look pretty I would choose numerous other individuals. Anyway, Holly is there for us to look at. Not many presenters can hold a candle to her in the looks department.

probably because its an entertainment show and not an olympic skating event

She get's on mine!! She just goes on and on without really 'saying' anything.

This.

She does her job just fine. Her comments aren't particularly meaningful, but if ITV wanted them to be, they would be.

You're a rotten lot, I hope Emma doesn't read this forum else she'll be as wicked as a wasp.

Even though she IS crap.

Entertainment show you say...

Let's replace those three with Harry Hill, Bungle from Rainbow and Harriet Harman.

Demonstrating how NOT to wear red lippie?

So are you saying ITV want to make a mug out of Emma? I don't agree...

I think she is there because she has a good agent and contacts and another reason I can't mention here.

But they've got Holly Booberly to fulfill that role.