My favourites are
Jacob Lusk
Casey Abrams
Naima Adedapo
Paul McDonald

with maybe Casey as my favourite but i'd like him to just sit here and sing at least once, don't know if he can do that though, this boy is a beast onstage.

and maybe Ashton Jones only because she makes me smile a little.

The others i find just plain boring. I'm happy Naima got through, i really like her.

Pia - I've been listenning to her on youtube, loving her.

Casey, Thia, Paul.

I love Pia <3 I don't mind Casey but I can see him joining the list of people like Taylor Hicks of those winners who never really make it.

Casey, Pia, Scott, Paul and Jacob. I voted for Casey this time though.

I'm going with Jacob and Naima. They both drew me in and made me want to listen. Not keen on James, Casey or Pia who seem to be the forum favourites.

Casey, Jacob and Pia.. Casey was brilliant in doing the Jessica Rabbit song during the Las Vegas round.. Jacob's range is amazing and Pia's got the talent and looks..

Bumping this back up

So you like only succesful singers? Thats great.

2009 and Taylor was still in the top 10 of Idol earners, he's actually done okay, not superstardom, but he makes a very nice living these days

I think the poster is responding to the fact that Casey is topping the poll, acknowledging it but saying they don't think he'll make it to the top

I like a few contestants but still no firm favourite. I voted for Paul, but after this week show, James may be my favourite.

I voted for Casey, but I also love, James, Jacob and scotty, equally.

1) Lauren.

2) Scotty.

3) Casey.

4) James.

5) Jacob.

So many favourites.. but it has to be James...followed by Pia, Casey, Scotty and Paul.

Casey love him. Don't get Paul at all, his voice sounds fake to me. Jacob way over the top, James thinks he's adam, but so isn't. Not much opinion on others yet.