Regardless of theme or whatever, what would you like to see them tackle?

Ashton- Work It Out (Beyonce)
Casey- Hit The Road Jack (Ray Charles)
Hailey- Damn Your Eyes (Etta James)
Jacob- Kissing You (Des'Ree)
James- Rainbow In The Dark (Dio)
Karen- Un-Break My Heart (Toni Braxton)
Lauren- Stuck Like Glue (Sugarland)
Naima- The Heart Of The Matter (India.Arie)
Paul- Romeo & Juliet (Dire Straits)
Pia- Release Me (Agnes)
Stefano- Hey, Soul Sister (Train)
Scotty- The Man Comes Around (Johnny Cash)
Thia- Broken Arrow (Pixie Lott)

Paul - Mr Bojangles (Was it Sammy Davis Jr?)
Haley - Last Dance (Donna Summer)

Haha big time doom songs for the 2 I don't like lol

How about....

Stefano - The Man Who Can't Be Moved (The Script)
James - Grace Kelly (Mika)
Karen - 1, 2, 3, 4 (Gloria Estefan) - I like your suggestion too OP, perhaps she could switch between it and Regresa A Mi
Lauren - Can't Fight The Moonlight (LeAnn Rimes)
Pia - I'm With You (Avril Lavigne) - Trying to think of a more upbeat one though

Those are my favourites so far, in no particular order other than the order in which i came up with the songs lol

Scotty - Ticket To Ride (The Beatles) - as my dad got me to do a Beatles theme and I can do an impression of Scotty singing this one
Naima - Tears Dry On Their Own (Amy Winehouse)
Ashthon - Take A Bow (Rihanna)
Jacob - Everybody In Love (JLS) - To update him a bit and give them some US publicity lol

The above group, I qite like, but they're not my faves

Most of those I came up with on the spot just now, I'm sure I could do better

Oops, forgot Casey and Thia. They both fir into my 3rd group.

Thia - I'm Like A Bird (Nelly Furtado)
Casey - I'm Yours (Jason Mraz) to suit his scatting and update him

xxxx

Ashton- Beyonce - Ring The Alarm
Casey- Joss Stone - L.O.V.E.
Hailey- Amy Winehouse - Love Is A Losing Game
Jacob- Nina Simone - Ain't Got No... I Got Life
James- Metallica - Nothing Else Matters
Karen- Shakira - Gypsy
Lauren- Dixie Chicks - Not Ready To Make Nice
Naima- Billie Holiday - Strange Fruit
Paul- Mumford & Sons - White Blank Page
Pia- Vanessa Carlton - 1000 Miles
Stefano- Beyonce - Listen (You probably think I'm mad but the sound is quite similar to his wild card performance)
Scotty- Johnny Cash - Personal Jesus
Thia- Paramore - The Only Exception

I like the idea of Ashthon doing "Work it Out" - it's well within her range, and she'd be able to show off a bit, without being completely overshadowed by the original.

I think it suits her personality- she has got that sassy vibe going on and she could make herself memorable with this.

Yeah Ashthon is one of my favorites so far and I like the suggestions of her singing Work It Out or Ring the Alarm, preferably Ring The Alarm as it's more different.

Are there themed weeks? I can't remember. I hope not though because I'm bored of contestants on this and X Factor singing the same songs we've heard millions of times before.

Yeah, this weeks theme is Musical Heroes.

Thanks .

Jacob : Always and Forever (Heatwave)

I would buy that!

These are the ones that spring to my mind for my favourites.

Pia
Stronger - Mary J Blige
Just Fine - Mary J Blige
I'm Every Woman - Whitney

Lauren
I hope - Dixie Chicks
Just a Dream - Carrie Underwood
I wonder - Kellie Pickler

Jacob
Part Time Lover - Stevie Wonder

Scotty - the phone book

The rest - 90 seconds of silence

Casey - Howlin' Wolf, Smokestack Lightning

Paul - Bat Out of Hell

Scotty - Bat Out of Hell

Voice Out Of Hell?

Soz, couldn't resist

Someone should sing Wanna Be Starting Something by Michael Jackson. I don't care who - maybe Stefano or James - it would just be funny to hear the studio version, the lyrics are hilarious!

xxxx

Paul singing Romeo & Juliet (Dire Straits), Wonderwall (Ryan Adams cover of Oasis), Don't Give Up On Me (Solomon Burke) would be nice. Or best of all, Ooh La La by The Faces.

I think that would definitely have to be taken off the list now, seeing as Sugarland are singing on the results show tonight

Also, Pia's choice? Can't see that happening in a million years LOL

I'd like to Naima sing fast car

I read that song suggestion on another Idol forum, but I think it was for Paul.

I adore the song, I don't think it's been covered previously on XF/idol has it? I wouldn't mind either Naima or Paul covering it.

Hence the title "Songs You'd LIKE to see them sing"

I picked that when I actually liked Pia- she is so dull now it's unreal.

Ashthon - You Might Need Somebody by Randy Crawford would have been good.
Pia - Get Here by Oleta Adams

Haley - It's a Man's Man's Man's World (James Brown)
Lauren - I Can't Make You Love Me (Bonnie Raitt/George Michael)
Pia - Chains (Tina Arena) or My Immortal (Evanescence)
Naima - My Funny Valentine (though agree with Fast Car)
Thia - Trouble Sleeping (Corinne Bailey Rae)

Paul - Drops of Jupiter (Train)
James - With Arms Wide Open (Creed)
Casey - That's the Way God Planned It (Billy Preston)
Jacob - A Change Is Gonna Come (Sam Cooke)
Stefano - Ordinary People (John Legend)
Scotty - Wicked Game (Chris Isaak)