Originally Posted by Dancc:
“I tend to agree with you. I was surprised to see some posters on here basically saying that the ratings for the upcoming BGT auditions are largely unimportant (in anticipation of a big drop) when the performance of SYTYCD's auditions have been under so much scrutiny on this thread. Is it a case of one rule for the ITV show, and another for the BBC show? Completely different beasts obviously, but if BGT is down by the extent that some are forecasting it will be a big story and dominating the ratings headlines for a different reason to usual.
I think the show will be down without Cowell but not as much as some are predicting and especially not for the first show due to the curiosity aspect.”
“I tend to agree with you. I was surprised to see some posters on here basically saying that the ratings for the upcoming BGT auditions are largely unimportant (in anticipation of a big drop) when the performance of SYTYCD's auditions have been under so much scrutiny on this thread. Is it a case of one rule for the ITV show, and another for the BBC show? Completely different beasts obviously, but if BGT is down by the extent that some are forecasting it will be a big story and dominating the ratings headlines for a different reason to usual.
I think the show will be down without Cowell but not as much as some are predicting and especially not for the first show due to the curiosity aspect.”
It's certainly an interesting one. I think so long as they're only down by 10-15% (max) then they shouldn't be too worried as they have lost Cowell, but like I said earlier (although without the %) any more than a 15% decline and I agree that alarm bells will be ringing. The ratings for the live shows are mrs important than the auditions but that doesn't mean that the ratings for the auditions aren't important as they are. The comparison with SYTYCD isn't really a good one as that show is down by a massive 32% on it's first 3 weeks last year and by 26% on last year's overall series average. Whilst there was bound to be a decline due to the show moving from January/February to April that level of decline is worrying, particularly as it couldn't really afford to lose too many viewers as last year's numbers weren't that great. BGT does have more breathing room in that respect, but if it does post % declines like SYTYCD then the panic button will definitely be pressed at ITV.




s but I see D.M.N. quite rightly beat me to it!