Thia has a good stage presence for a 16 year old, with a voice to match.

Not sure that song for her, sounded a safe one to me


5/10 for not trying harder

Nice voice, pretty girl, dreadful song

Yes, so was Scotty.

Tia, what a lovely voice she has. Would like to hear her sing something up to date, to prove she is relevant and current.

Randy - "pageant"

Have to agree with Randy there

Glad the judges agreed with me.

Jennifer has nice hair tonight.

If Thia's in the bottom 2/3 because of the boring song choice I'll be mad. She has so much potential.


wtf!
That's even scarier. His voice sounds about 20-30 years older than he is.

Bon Jovi gonna rock the night after the ads...

I think James D might do it justice........................

Please James - excite us with your rock.

Ryan and James sitting down, just so people don't take further notice of the ridiculous size-difference between the two of them.

Is it me or is the band completely over powering them tonight?

Pity the hippo isn't on AI as he'd beat them all. lol Hippo star of AI!

James thinks he's already a big star with all that hand over head clapping. Music sounds better than he does


3/10

I never thought I'd actually ever want James to sing louder than he does.
It was tough to hear him.

Think I've worked out why I'm okay with James, but never likely to really love him, his voice is too generic for me, if I heard him on the radio I don't think I'd immediately know it was James, it could be a lot of people - oh, and cut out the shrieking, it's not nice, not clever and not in tune

Think I'd rather have Jon Jovi as James was woeful tonight. Stage-wise he was ok, but rest dull.

Randi's "very tastefully dude"....was the funny part.

I care not about his boots.

Haley born in 1990. Has nice hair too.

What language does Haley sing in

Have to agree and I LIKE James.

When Jon BJ sings it he has a real depth to his voice and perfect phrasing - it all sounded a bit monotone, disappointed, thought he'd do better

Haley - trainwreckish.

Haley.....unsure about this. With all that walking off stage you'd swear she was miming, mind you she can talk that part.

5/10

The sound mix on that was totally different to last night, East coast feed anyway. The band was barely audible for some of them. They sounded more out of tune as well. Just saying.
They cut some of his interview out too.

I reckon they edited it for the West coast.

Maybe he just went overboard with his style tonight, as it had that feeling. Maybe he'll be better next time.