sorry meant to say hi
I usually watch both shows together on a Saturday morning but thought I'd watch live tonight so hi everyone.
Love Scotty before he even sings but the show on a whole has been a little disappointing for me so far. Think the girls could do better .

Jgwb!

lol Casey's first line 'Load up on guns', never thought I'd hear that sung on Idol.

Now this is my problem with Casey, very, very talented musician, but a singer, not so hot, very average, and the growl seems very forced and he lacks range - that was all a bit of a mess

Casey likes his parents a lot. Casey is 20.

rock number with guitar. Band louder than he is. Fluffed that jump at the end, but what a performance all the same, looked as if he was meant for the stage.

8/10

Jennifer loves him SO much.

I wish they turned the mics up, you could hear that his voice was managing the song but it just wasn't loud enough.

Love Kacey

theres something bizarre about caseys face & i dont mean his beard! lol its like theres been jigsaws of a few different faces & the pieces have been mixed up & put back together all mixed up! each of his features seem out of proportion to each other.

lol at Randy mentioning huge bands Muse and Radiohead, and then Lykke Li. The only song I've heard from her is that 'There's a possibility....' song in the Twilight film New Moon.

Lauren reminds me so much of Kelly Clarkson.

jeez, lauren's dad looks so young! her mum looks like mutton dressed as lamb dressed like that

Bad beginning, she's brought it back a bit now, but a bit overpowered by the band again

i couldnt understand a word of that at the beginning! i think the band seems way too loud or is it just me lol

Lauren A..... 16 years old, looksmore like in her 20s.

starts off low toned. Music too loud, drowing her voice too much.

Don't think it's right song for her.


4/10

16-20 year olds on Idol look more like 20-25 year olds or maybe even older, whereas 16-20 year olds on UK X Factor look more like they are 10-14 year olds.

'if you want some shitting in your life'

stupid advert, stupid show

She's 16? Oh dear, good job she can sing a bit.

Can anyone explain the mystery that is Olly Murs continued success to me

Surely Jacob doesn't need to be on last?

'Becoz e nuf fit init, an becoz o ma wurd e stripd off dis week!!!'

I can't bear him, he's a bit of a sleazeball.

loving jacob doing this, he needs to keep away from doing the luther vandross tribute act and i thought that was great!

Jacob born in 1987

Alone....powerful voice to get over the loudness of the music. Or at least he's trying to make his voice heard.

What I can hear sounds very good.

10/10

If Jacob doesn't start reigning it in soon he's going to explode before many more weeks are out

Vocal run after run after run after run - just sing the flipping song why don't you.

Paul and Jacob, we might well be breaking up this week

Jacob - the best of the night.

Jacob's voice is very nice on the ears to say it's so loud, unlike James's screeching.

Steven: "The gospel had a baby and they named it Jason...Jacob Lusk."
Fail!

Randi excited for the 3rd time tonight. . lol

Overall the guys beat the gals tonight, imo. Enjoyed the show.