Karen Rodriguez. She was in the bottom 3 with Haley (again) and Naima. She sung Hero by Mariah Carey as her save song and basically begged to be saved by the judges but they said no.

I wasn't keen on Karen's performance and I hope Haley goes next week, she leaves me cold. Not keen on Naima either

I don't have a clue what is going on. Ashthon and Karen weren't great but they both a million times better than Paul, he's actually one of the worst contestants I've ever seen on the lives of American Idol. Paul to go next.

Really annoyed, had a gut instinct to change my bottom two to Karen going and Haley staying, but I didn't - grrr, on for a perfect score there - the way it's going I can see Pia, Thia and Naima (scrapping in at 10th place) as the only girls on the tour

Karen
Haley
Naima

with Karen and Naima in the sing off and Karen leaving

Bottom 2 were Karen and Haley. Karen bottom, got the chance to sing for her place, judges didn't use the save and David sang her home

You forgot to mention Lauren .....

So it's Pia & Lauren (safe), Thia, Naima & Haley.
IMO Thia, Naima and Haley in next week bottom 3 with Haley going

Yeah, it wasn't a huge surprise but I was really hoping that Haley would avoid the bottom 3. I thought she did a good job on Tuesday.
As some posters have put it, it's gonna be a sausage fest this year - Naima and Haley will be out probbaly in the next two weeks. With Thia picking quite dull songs I imagine she'll follow too.
The only guy I think at risk of being in the bottom soon is Jacob. I would say Paul, but after getting through this week he must have a loyal following!

Would rather Naima had gone this week

Be interesting to see how Scotty deals with that