Last week on American Idol, the Top 13 sang songs by Musical Heroes and after a Bottom 3 starring Karen, Ashthon and Stefano, it was Stefano who found himself leaving.

This week, the Top 12 will tackle Songs from their birth Year!

Okay, here is a recap of the performances:


Okay Lines are now open!!!!!!!!!!!!

They close at 8pm tonight with results shortly after.

Here is the names list:

Ashthon Jones
Casey Abrams
Haley Reinhart
Jacob Lusk
James Durbin
Karen Rodriguez
Lauren Alaina
Naima Adedapo
Paul McDonald
Pia Toscano
Scotty McCreery
Thia Megia

ooooh what's this?? Is it a comptition just for fun?

I haven't been on long so I missed the top 13, can I still join plz? x

yes just pm me your rankings from 12 (favourite) to 1 (least favourite).

The performances are above, Stefano was eliminated so I gave Ashthon a song myself

ok - count me in!

Ok, pm me your rankings

Lines extended to 9pm

I think I might have caused an upset with my high ranking of somebody most people might not like.

If you want me to, I'll happily pick songs for someone if needed..

Lines close in just 5 minutes, it's very close, one vote could change it all.

OK, Can I please call forward Ashthon, Karen and Naima

Ashthon, you sang Greatest Love Of All, after last week's Bottom 3 appearance, people thought you came back fighting and were generally very impressed but can you avoid the Bottom Three again?

Karen, you sang Love Will Lead You Back, you were also in the Bottom 3 last week and unfortunately, not everyone was completely convinced that you had done enough to avoid it this week. But will you?

Naima, you sang What's Love Got To Do With It. It was said to be seriously pitchy, out of tune and rough. The only redemption was your performance skills. Has it lead to a bottom 3 appearance for you?

Ashthon, please take a seat over at the............

couches because you are safe!!!!!!!!.

As are you Naima Adedapo!!!!!!!!!!!!

However, Karen you arein the bottom 3!!!!!!

So Naima, join Ashthon and the others on the couches, Karen please take the first stool.

Next up, can I have Scotty, Thia and Haley.

Scotty, you sang Can I Trust You With My Heart, again it was good but many people raised issues about how your songs were too similar unfortunately. Will this lead to your downfall?

Thia, you sang Colours Of The Wind, again it was popular with the viewers but there were slight conflicts over whether or not your ballads were interesting enough. Have you avoided the bottom 3?

And finally, Haley, you sang I'm Your Baby Tonight, last week you were criticized for your song choice and this week was no better as your vocals were criticized. Did the voters agree?

Scotty and Thia, you are both safe!!!!!!!!!

Haley, you are in the bottom 3!!!!!

Scotty and Thia, join Ashthon on the Safe Couches. Haley, join Karen at the stools.

Could we now please have Casey, Paul and James.

Casey, you sang Smell Likes Teen Spirit, whilst you were commended for taking a risk with a song that isnt typical of American Idol, people felt that it wasn't a great vocal.

Paul, you sang I Guess That's Why They Call It The Blues, after last week's performance, people felt that it wasn't much of an improvement saying that your vocals were yet again flawed.

And James, you sang I'll Be There For You, the performance was praised but the arrangement of the song was criticized.

Who is safe?

Before I reveal it, I can tell you that Pia, Lauren and Jacob, you have not been called because you are all safe!!!!!!!!!!!

That means that it is now between Paul, James and Casey for the last Bottom Three place, that person is..........

Paul McDonald!!!!!!!!!!!

Paul, you are in the Bottom 3!!!!!!!!!

Please join Karen and Haley at the stools.

James and Casey, well done.

Right Karen, Paul and Haley. I can first reveal that...........

Karen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The Spanish diva is safe but now it's between Haley and Paul for the last guaranteed spot in next week's show. Remember the Save has not been used yet. Okay, the singer who must sing for their place in the competition is.........

Paul McDonald!!!!!!!!!!!

Well done Haley, you are safe. Okay singing for the possibility of being saved is Paul!!!!!!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h9PpdzUOZHo

Please pm me your decision as to whether to save him or not by 10pm.

Remember that the save can be used only once

Okay, the result has been decided. This was not a unanimous decision but I can tell you Paul that you are

NOT being saved.

Sorry Paul, okay that means we have our Top 11!!!!!

Join me next week on Saturday or Sunday (will be confirmed) for the Top 11 Voting.

Good Night!

Woooooh!

My number 1 went out *happyface*

Sorry Paul fans. :P

Thanks for doing this kevin