Poll: Do you want Emma Bunton to judge next year?
Yes, I do
Not fussed either way
No, I don't
Yes, I do
Not fussed either way
No, I don't
Results:Do you want Emma Bunton to judge for next season?
Yes, I do.
11 (9.91%)
Not fussed either way.
11 (9.91%)
No, I don't.
89 (80.18%)
Voters: 111. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Poll: Do you want Emma Bunton to judge net year?
I'd say no I certainly do not, she was a complete diaster last night and didn't know what she was on about for the series.
* Was meant to say next and disaster in my previous posts,*
Anyway I feel a bit neglected that none of you are getting involved in this poll/discussion and would like some participation please.
Anyway I feel a bit neglected that none of you are getting involved in this poll/discussion and would like some participation please.
Originally Posted by jaspers mum:
“Nope. Let her put her expert knowledge to being a contestant
”
“Nope. Let her put her expert knowledge to being a contestant
”
Definetely.
when they cut the number of Judges down it just totally exposed her weakness.
she didnt have one of the pro Judges to hide behind
Really hope she doesnt come back.
she didnt have one of the pro Judges to hide behind
Really hope she doesnt come back.
Originally Posted by oathy:
“when they cut the number of Judges down it just totally exposed her weakness.
she didnt have one of the pro Judges to hide behind
Really hope she doesnt come back.”
“when they cut the number of Judges down it just totally exposed her weakness.
she didnt have one of the pro Judges to hide behind
Really hope she doesnt come back.”
So do I.
No I don't. She has too many 'favourites' and at times is completely rubbish with her analysis. Plus she overmarks way too much
Absolutely not.
I preferred it when we had a panel of 5 using the traditional scoring I associate with ice dancing. But if we have to go to 3, then the majority should be skaters. Jason may be over-the-top with his offensive comments at time but at least he does have a strong dance background to be able to give guidance on performance.
Going to a kids' stage school, being in a girl group and finishing 3rd on Strictly does not qualify Emma. She is not a dance or skating professional so has absolutely no place on the panel.
I preferred it when we had a panel of 5 using the traditional scoring I associate with ice dancing. But if we have to go to 3, then the majority should be skaters. Jason may be over-the-top with his offensive comments at time but at least he does have a strong dance background to be able to give guidance on performance.
Going to a kids' stage school, being in a girl group and finishing 3rd on Strictly does not qualify Emma. She is not a dance or skating professional so has absolutely no place on the panel.
No thanks. Nice enough woman, but too little knowledge of both skating and performance. Any member of the audience who has watched the show from series 1, and has listened to, and learned from, experienced skaters / ice dancers such as Robin, Nicky or Karen would be able to judge to a similar, possibly even higher level.
No. I've changed my mind about her recently. Her favourites and her gushing about men is so annoying! Very unprofessional.
I'd like to have a skater in to judge content - I got annoyed when she justified giving high(ish) marks to Johnson because the baby kicked during the routine!
No. Alesha Dixon on SCD has just about become okay, but Emma is just so bad; she knows nothing and it shows. She is after 2 years on the same level Alesha was during her first season, since when she has improved to become just about okay; but Emma is if anything getting worse and more vacuous as a judge.
