Originally Posted by darkjedimaster:
“Scotty is a one trick pony”
“Scotty is a one trick pony”
But what a superb trick of being able to hold the audience so well that they love him, and can sing too. Yeah, very good trick.
Performance show thread 31/3/11 thurs uk pace
2 of 10
But what a superb trick of being able to hold the audience so well that they love him, and can sing too. Yeah, very good trick.
Originally Posted by darkjedimaster:
“Scotty is a one trick pony”
“Scotty is a one trick pony”
So is Carrie Underwood. I rest my case.
Originally Posted by Dix:
“But what a superb trick of being able to hold the audience so well that they love him, and can sing too. Yeah, very good trick.”
“But what a superb trick of being able to hold the audience so well that they love him, and can sing too. Yeah, very good trick.”
Exactly.
Originally Posted by ibeca:
“So is Carrie Underwood. I rest my case.”
“So is Carrie Underwood. I rest my case.”
And exactly. He knows the type of artist he will be after this, and he's proving week after week that he's great at what he does. I guess I just don't buy into the idea that they have to show versatility. He's hardly going to be singing disco numbers after the show, so why do it now?
Originally Posted by shelleyj89:
“And exactly. He knows the type of artist he will be after this, and he's proving week after week that he's great at what he does. I guess I just don't buy into the idea that they have to show versatility. He's hardly going to be singing disco numbers after the show, so why do it now?”
“And exactly. He knows the type of artist he will be after this, and he's proving week after week that he's great at what he does. I guess I just don't buy into the idea that they have to show versatility. He's hardly going to be singing disco numbers after the show, so why do it now?”
Agreed. If a contestant, or any artist, can perform in various style equally well I have no problem with them demonstrating that. However, if a contestant has a strong suit and it's a great strength, as Scotty's Country style is, why not make the most of what your gift is?
Originally Posted by ibeca:
“Agreed. If a contestant, or any artist, can perform in various style equally well I have no problem with them demonstrating that. However, if a contestant has a strong suit and it's a great strength, as Scotty's Country style is, why not make the most of what your gift is?”
“Agreed. If a contestant, or any artist, can perform in various style equally well I have no problem with them demonstrating that. However, if a contestant has a strong suit and it's a great strength, as Scotty's Country style is, why not make the most of what your gift is?”
I completely agree.
Is it Bob Marley week now? 
She needs to keep standing out though, after busting a move last week I think she now realizes it.
She needs to keep standing out though, after busting a move last week I think she now realizes it.
This isn't working - especially the fake Jamaican accent - I like her but this is a bit cringey.............
We is back.... 
Naima......I'm Still Standing....different style, should be interesting.
Looks good... song & performance...not that spectacular to me, dull in parts, needs more oomph.
5/10
Naima......I'm Still Standing....different style, should be interesting.
Looks good... song & performance...not that spectacular to me, dull in parts, needs more oomph.
5/10
Originally Posted by Conehead:
“Scotty is cheesy. I didn't understand a word till the chorus. Hope no one does 'Sacker if aiss'.”
“Scotty is cheesy. I didn't understand a word till the chorus. Hope no one does 'Sacker if aiss'.”
The only cheese there is the guy who thinks he's cool. The rocker who can't sing or perform without cliched phrasing and poses and telegraphed (and flat) high notes.
haha that faux Jamaican accent was funny. Not sure the song worked with the Reggae twist but at least it wasn't boring!
I admire her for doing that. I thought it was interesting and not as bad as I feared when I heard what she was doing! Not entirely sure it worked though.
Originally Posted by Conehead:
“Please Naima - not with that accent!”
“Please Naima - not with that accent!”
Oh good god! what is she thinking.... what on earth are the judges gonna say
JLo oIf ever proof were needed that this year's panel know as much about what they're talking about as a flea on my dog's back, ......... ladies and gentlemen, I give you the comments on Naima and her song choice.
while you lot are lusting after scotty, that surely means that steven tyler is waiting for me
he really grooves my truffles!
he really grooves my truffles!
Originally Posted by Damanda:
“Oh good god! what is she thinking.... what on earth are the judges gonna say”
“Oh good god! what is she thinking.... what on earth are the judges gonna say”
it was the fake accent that did it for me, kept reminding me of jim davidson
There's something about Paul that's a bit....sleazy.
He sounded like Steven Tyler when he asked the crowd how they were doing.
He sounded like Steven Tyler when he asked the crowd how they were doing.
Originally Posted by ibeca:
“The only cheese there is the guy who thinks he's cool. The rocker who can't sing or perform without cliched phrasing and poses and telegraphed (and flat) high notes.”
“The only cheese there is the guy who thinks he's cool. The rocker who can't sing or perform without cliched phrasing and poses and telegraphed (and flat) high notes.”
I like Scotty, he seems nice, but he is sooooo cheesy and corny and oh well you get the picture.
Such a shame. The montage at the start of the show and the whole theme of Elton makes me wonder what a previous contestant would have been like performing an Elton John song.
Originally Posted by ladyloulou:
“while you lot are lusting after scotty, that surely means that steven tyler is waiting for me he really grooves my truffles!”
“while you lot are lusting after scotty, that surely means that steven tyler is waiting for me
he really grooves my truffles!”
no no no I bagged him ages ago... ask Megs
2 of 10
