ok well i think Thia, Paul Stefano and Naima were the least interesting tonight.

If it were my choice I'd loose Stefano and Thia. I dont think either of them have much scope for improving or showing us something different.

Better than me - I cleaned the oven earlier and I'm still wearing most of it! Time for a bath as soon as this is finished

Could do well in a seedy night club, as that's how her performance came across. But each to their own.

I must have watched it on a bad stream last night because i was wondering why Adam Lambert loved Haley's performance but watching it again it was the best of the night imo.

thanks all for an entertaining evening, will reconvene tomorrow for the results, paul and naima to go for me,

First time I've even noticed Haley.

I think Stefano and Paul should go!

I suppose the fact that reality show loving Robbie hasn't commented on him or anyone else on the show this year is a sort of sign of how naff he is and most of them are

Shouts through megaphone...MEGLOS! We using this Thread for tomorrow I take It? Oh leave message and will read it tomorrow ok, thanks.

Have a good evening, thanks for Thread too, was fun as usual. xxx

night all, see yous tomorrow.

and just when you thought the excitement was all over, on discovery james cracknell is about to get a back sack and crack wax!

I dont have a fav.... i feel differently about them each week.

I think Haley and Naima are the best of the girls and Scotty James and Casey are best of the boys. I did like jacob, but he's making my toes curl now... not in the way that David Ginola makes my toes curl

Sometimes the live streaking doesn't do vocals justice.

I thought Haley was great tonight and she never did it for me before though I never felt she's deserved to be in the bottom three so far.

I think a new thread is better, hardly anyone here last friday, maybe because there was no thread for the results show.

really? i thought it was fantastic!

playing catch-up sorry!

oh & i REALLY dont get the scotty love, he's so amateurish & boring!

Poor Naima, that experiment with her voice didn't really work.
Think that Paul probably should go, I suspect he knew he was bad since he couldn't stop playing to the crowd asking them if they were alright. Trying to inject some life into the proceedings.
Get rid of Stefano too.

Poor Thia, she seems to potentially have this cute quirky style but she has been given probably the worst song choices of all. At 15 she must have more life to her, surely.


*shouts back* YES WE MIGHT ASWELL!!!!

Bye y'all (as Scotty would say )
xxxxxxxxx

really? where ? Are they showing it live.... blimey Im getting old

James? Are you serious? A woman who likes Tyler, Jagger and Rogers among other? James? Have you ever been to Butlins?

Live streaking? That's a first. Anything for votes I suppose

thats quite rude I think, I'm gonna leave it here
bye

I like Scotty, Jacob. Pia was good tonight, the best for her, imo. Didn't think Jacob's song was that great. But reckon James could be the dark horse, and also like Paul. Naima is good too, and like her different style, although she wasn't great tonight performance-wise. I don't mind who wins as long as they give decent performances and not look like eejits.

cheers

haha! i'm surprised i quite enjoyed his song, i normally hate his performances because looking at him freaks me out!

lol or like he's got melted chocolate in the back of his throat.

PMSL @ the dramatics! oh dear! & whats with the Elvis lip curling?

LOVED Haley tonight, agree with Randy, best of the night, still think she might struggle with the votes, hope not though. Casey was brilliant aswell, no chance him being bottom 3 i think.

In danger Naima, Thia, Paul, possibly Jacob, and Haley even though she doesn't deserve to be.

Jacob really looked as though he was going to burst into tears!

Loved Haley tonight, thought she was great. The song was perfect for her. I love that she takes chances with her songs. And I was doing the same scrunch-face that JLo was on the 'BENNIIEEE BENNIIIIEE' parts

Some good performances - Scotty. Lauren, Haley, Casey.

Some OK performances - Pia, Thia, Jacob, Stefano, Naima.

Some awful performances - James, Paul.



Probably a little strongly phrased but quite true really. James is a joke but at least he's one that gets funnier by the week.