Last week on DS American Idol, the Top 9 tackled the Best of Elton John and in a shocking twist, James Durbin was eliminated! Tonight, the remaining 8 contestants tackle songs from the Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame. Here are the recaps:


And the names for voting are:


To vote, pm me the name from 8 (Best) to 1 (Worst). Lines close tomorrow night at 8pm

Lines extended to 8pm tonight. Get your votes in!

Okay, the lines are closed, 8 acts stand but only 7 can remain, it's time for American Idol's Top 8 Results!

Firstly, I'd like to call up Pia Toscano, Naima Adedapo and Ashthon Jones

Ashthon, you sang ''Son Of A Preacher Man'' by Dusty Springfield for your Rock N Roll Hall Oof Fame Track, the judges loved it and said that it was edgy, sassy and everything you could do good.

Pia, you sang ''River Deep, Mountain High'' by Tina Turner and Ike. The judges commended your passion and said the performance was good but asked you to deliver more.

Naima, you sang ''One Love'' by Bob Marley. The judges loved your reggae flavour and called it your best yet but felt the public may want more.

One of you is in the Bottom 3 and that person is.

Naima Adedapo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Commiserations Naima, you are in the Bottom 3 for the second week in a row. Congratulations to Pia and Ashthon, you are safe, take a seat at the stools Naima, girls join the others at the couches.

Okay, next up, the other girls, Lauren Alaina, Thia Megia and Karen! Rodriguez

Lauren, you sang ''Natural Woman'' by Aretha! The judges loved that you took a risk and felt that you did hit the big notes but just felt you needed a bit more control over the vocals.

Thia, you sang ''Piece Of My Heart'' by Janis Joplin. The judges felt you came on leaps and bounds doing a more rocky song and loved your passion.

Karen, you sang ''I Feel Good'' by Soulman James Brown. Karen, the judges were split with Randy questioning the direction you're going in but Stephen and Jennifer loving your performance skills.

Thia, you are safe

Okay, Karen and Lauren. One of you is safe, one is bottom three. Okay, the result is:

Karen, please join Naima in the bottom three

Lauren, join Thia, Ashthon and Pia at the couches.

Okay, after the break, we'll see which of Scotty and Jacob joins the boys in the bottom three.

Yikes, long break. Must be a HUGE KitKat.

It's interesting how this has developed, with half of the contestants having been eliminated from the main one.
I might actually prefer this group to be honest.

Sorry for keeping you guys.

Scotty, you sang ''That's All Right'' by The King of Rock N Roll. The judges loved your passion for the performance and thought it was a very good vocal but wondered where you would go next.

Jacob you sang ''Man In The Mirror'' by MJ. The judges said the vocals were good but you lacked the edge you had shown previously.

I can reveal that Scotty, you are..................

in the bottom three!!!!!!!!!!!!

Well done Jacob however Scotty, you join the other two in the bottom three.

Now, Karen, Naima and Scotty. I'll relieve one of you. That person is.....................

Karen Rodriguez!!!!!!!!!!!

Well done Karen, okay Naima and Scotty. The public have voted and the act possibly going home tonight is.............

Scotty Mc Creery!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yes, it's a shock. Naima, please join the others. Scotty, I'm sorry but you must now sing for survival.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sPjYO_kbqjM

Viewers must pm me by 22:45pm telling me whether they want Scotty to be saved or to be eliminated. The majority of votes decides.

Shocked by that result!! Thought Naima was a goner...

Should Scotty be saved in your opinion carlisle?

No.

Scotty, with 4 votes to 0, you are...................

eliminated!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Sorry Scotty.

Well there we have it, a shock elimination bringing our Top 8 down to 7 with just 1 boy remaining. Who will go? Goodnight and join us again next week when the Top 7 tackle Movie songs.

It's funny how completely opposite this show is to reality. XDD

Scotty not in it anymore, yeah so I prefer the other group then.