Originally Posted by Mr. Fahrenheit:
“In fairness, Britney fans were saying this in 2004, but she went batshit crazy, Madonna fans were saying that in 1989, but then she did Erotica, Prince fans were saying this in 1985, but then he did ''The Artist Formerly Known As...'', etc. You can't predict anything. The next one doesn't have to be more talented, they just have to be more successful, or beautiful, or media savvy, or whatever.
The horrible thing is, people say Little Monsters are crazy now - just wait until she's not the big girl in the playground anymore. It's the same thing with Britney fans now. Many can't accept that there's someone bigger than her now, hence all the bitchiness. And again, same with Madonna fans when Britney was much bigger at the start of the last decade.
It's the Music food chain, and not just Pop. Lady GaGa isn't a victim here - far from it - she's just another in a long line of musicians that are huge now, but will become less successful as the years go on. It's not because she'll be shit or old, it's because she won't have as many casual fans. People will be used to ''The Lady GaGa Sound'', and just won't be interested.”
Well look, I wasn't trying to make a big statement about anything before. Although I am a Gaga fan - I just love her music and love what she does (most of the time), I wouldn't count myself as a huge fan, nowhere near as much as most of the guys in this thread are. I rarely visit any Gaga-specific websites and I'm not as up-to-date with all things Gaga other than her music. She's not even my favourite artist, by a fair distance. So I'm just saying all this stuff how I see it as a neutral pop fan.
I'm not saying she's going to continue to sell 10-15 million of every album she releases for the next 20 years, and obviously she won't be as huge as she is now forever - especially with the way the pop world is now, but we really haven't seen anyone quite like her in mainstream pop for absolutely ages. She's not just a typical popstar of the moment, for all sorts of reasons which don't need me to spend ages listing. But aside from all the things that make her stand out (for better or worse), she does have the core abilities as a musician and songwriter, which means she never has to just rely on other people for her music. Whether that makes a difference in terms of her popularity in years' time, who knows, but it's certainly an advantage, as well as being a great asset to have.