Which contestant is each judge's personal favourite?

I have an idea that Jacob is probably Jennifer's favourite, she gets so emotionally involved when he is in full flow, but I'm not certain who would be Steven's or Randy's favourite contestant.

Does Steven likes James best, and Randy like either Haley 'Joplin' or Scotty?

Or did the fact they all saved Casey indicate that he is the universal judges' pet?

I would say Steven's is James, J. Lo definitely has a soft spot for Stefano (like me) and Randy does like Haley, but hasn't always shown such enthusiasm for her, another one both he and Steven love is Lauren.

Scotty seems to be a universal favourite, with judges and viewers, and I wouldn't say Casey tops that. He was lucky to have been bottom on top 11 night, and I reckon they'll be regretting that save now they've lost Pia. Jacob seems more of a universal favourite than a particular J.Lo fave. Along with Stefano, she loved Karen - that'll be why the decision on Karen wasn't unanimous.

xxxx

It's hard to tell because they are so enthusiastic about everyone. But either way the pimping is far less obvious on AI. The X Factor is blatant and frustrating, last year it was outrageous to the point that Dermot practically lied to voters.

I wonder if the judges will be more critical now that so many people have complained about them.

If the AI judges had to mentor the acts, I wonder who they'd pick?

xxxx

I have given them all some acts! I gave Randy the extra.

Randy:
Casey
Scotty
Haley
Ashthon
Thia

JLo:
Karen
Stefano
Jacob
Pia

Steven:
Lauren
James
Naima
Paul

The next person to suggest the Judges probably now regret saving Casey gets a slap!

I don't think they regret it.

Sounds good, though I could see Naima with Randy, and perhaps Paul with Steven as a result.

I would have Stefano, James, Karen and either Lauren or Pia (or both if I was taking over from Randy) or maybe Scotty bo balance it out a bit!

And I don't fancy being slapped lol. Not that Casey's not talented or doesn't deserve his place. I just have lots of other favourites and so do the judges. I just saw Pia as being higher up their collective list than Casey

xxxx

do you mean scotty or casey?

I would be greedy and snaffle up casey, scotty and stefano from the boys and lauren from the girls. Pia if I had a fifth.

Probably. I think Casey. I just knew it wasn't Stefano so put whatever came into my head lol you can leave him well alone, glad you like him though

xxxx