I hate this song Stefano is singing. He's singing it ok but it's really not my think. Bottom 3 again I think this week!

Ah come off it Randi.. you say that each time to different contestants...in it to win it...rubbish!

Stefano's got a good voice, but some songs...please!

Setting Stefano up for a redemption comeback vote perhaps? All this sympathy is making me feel sorry for him, and I actually want him eliminated.
Right now his elimination would be so predictably boring that I would prefer someone else to go (Paul).
One of my faves better not go this week though humph!

I agree with Randy - his best so far. But I still don't care.

12 year old fancies Scotty..think she's too young.

sad i know but i love that song , but stefano's version was not good, i dont think it helped that it was originally a song with several good voices in, to take it to a solo takes the life out of it for me, oooh surprise scotty is doing a country song!

Scotty says that he is going "Back to his Country roots" but isn't that what he has done each and every week?!? I actually think Scotty will win the whole thing but it's getting a bit dull hearing him sing what sounds like the same song each week! Definitely this performance will appeal to middle America.....

Scotty can sing love songs too.

Scotty....10/10

Love songs...0/10

Go Scotty, but don't do love songs...

can you imagine the tumbleweed if there was a thread titled
jennifer & stevens nasty judging comments! have they ever said anything remotely critical??

Was she a lollipop lady?

Casey and Nat King Cole....never!
ads

Judging by this week and last week, the girls can't resist him it seems.

Scotty has a great vocal, but he has to be careful he doesn't become too divisive. Instead of making people decide whether they like Scotty or not, it might become about whether people like country music or not.
It's not there yet because I think Scotty is great and don't like country music, but if he reaches the final could the novelty have worn off by then? Hmmm.

I still think Scotty sounds like he's doing an impersonation of one of his singing heroes. His performances are full of mannerisms.

Aw Stefano seemed soooooooo nervous, felt bad for him but loved his vocals and was pleased that he was proud of himself and showing off his lovely smile again! I disagree that it was his best performance, but I'll take that as the judges trying to help him get through, so I won't complain!

About 8 out of 10, would've been higher with a more upbeat song and less unfortunate title!

My mum and I would've preferred Everybody's Talking from Scotty. He sang well but the song was too indulgent. He's lucky he's a voters' fave as othewrwise, he wouldn't be reeling in many floaters. Within his capabilities he could quite easily show more versatility than he's doing as yet.

6.5 out of 10

xxxx

:yawn:
/!\

just realised why i'm really not bothered if i watch anymore..............its become nothing more than vomit-inducing crap since simon cowell left.

i'm out

No, she was a young female, with beautiful hair and a face, told her she should go into movies, or be a model, as she'd got all the attributes. I had never seen such a beautiful face on a female like her face was in all the years I've lived here. Don't think the motorists did either.

Heart-throb Casey next....

Casey looks like a farmer tonight.
I'm starting to feel like he's more of a musician than a singer, his voice sounds totally spent.

I like Casey but think this will land him in the bottom 3 as the majority just won't "get it"!

Casey trying to be Nat King Cole...er no, why not be himself with that song.

randy is such a name dropper lol

Casey was being true to himself, it's NOTHING like the way Nat King Cole sang it

I love Casey's choice of song - but he lost my support with that performance.

Paul - Not great tonight. To me his mic sounded like it was far too low, and his voice didn't sound great. Boring song choice as well.

Lauren - Didn't like her before. Still don't now. Couldn't have picked a more predictable and cheesy song unless she had gone down the "I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman" Britney route...

Stefano - Yawn. Don't get this guy.

Scotty - Actually my fave performance by him so far. Still not a fan - it's not my sort of music - but he was good. For the first time I don't mind if he stays for another week!

Casey - Thank goodness he's in this competition! I absolutely love him. His voice wasn't at its absolute best tonight, but the performance itself still worked. As Randy said, there's a definite gap in the market for his records, and he's going to sell records once this show finishes, whether he wins or not.

I agree. To me it was somewhere between the original and the more musical-theatre / easy listening-style Daniel Boys version (which I love). He made it his own, in his own jazz style that suits him so well.