That song isnt good enough, doesnt stretch her enough, but she did it well. She has talent,there is some room for improvement, but she's young, give her a few more years.
Middle of the pack for me.

He is just so far away from the mark. Thats a crap song , but it is very easy to sing. He has almost no personal charm either, seems a bit dim to me.
Randy talks such nonsense these days, he says everyone is killing it!

so says you, who posted a comment full of spelling mistakes and typos

I'm fairly happy go lucky on here but i think comments about typos etc are rude and pointless and against the guidance for what makes a happy and respectful forum.
You can delete

Yes, he can only do that... which i guess is fine, because he wants to be a country singer. He is fine, he's dull to me though.
No shame in that, but paul rogers could sing country, or ballands, garage or pop... I doubt he would... but he could.

Rewatched him... he looks like he is being a 48 year old. Im sure he is a nice boy really but this wholesome country boy thing is making me want to turn him off.

I agree, it doesnt help that he sang Nats song, that man was a singer beyond compare.
Casey has his strengths.. but he seems out of his depth to me

Not exactly respectful calling someone dim who you don't even know

I may give an opinion about someones performance, an honest critique, but I have NEVER personally attacked or been disrespectful to any of the contestants. *shakes her head*

Not her best by a long way, but i thought she did well to recover from the first bum note.

She looked bloody marvellous. She is the best girl left and has been for a while but she is middle of the pack tonight.

She better choose her song more carefully next week.

At least they criticised her, i think that because they know she can do better....

Jacob is corny.... and I've come to the conclusion that he is a slimy creep..... sorry

He can sing fine ... not great... but fine, however, he is thoroughly unlikeable

that's totally uncalled for

James no Ozzy tho..... I quite liked that, Im a bit worried that I did.

Im commenting on the show, you seem to be criticising me..

i'm gonna terminate my communication with you, i think its for the best .

All things considered I think Paul and Stefano are the weakest of the remaining contestants. I'd like them both to go in the next 2 weeks.
The strongest at the moment seem to be Scotty, Hayley and James. Lauren, Casey and Jacob a bit dodgy.
I dont really favour any of them.

..... OK, if you say so

Thank Goodness.Paul and Stefano are in the bottom 3. I think haley is too good to be there with them, but that wasnt her best performance tonight.
I think Stefano is the weakest but i hope Paul goes, I dont want to see that inane grinning anymore as he struggles to perform. He's a talented musician, I hope he finds a good career in music, but he isnt the American Idol.

Fair enough in my view.
Ta ra paul.. I rather enjoyed that version of Maggie May.
Good Luck to him.

I'm not sure I have a favourite yet this year, it was Scotty but hate to say it, he is getting a little dull, although I do enjoy his duets with Lauren.

I'm not into the James thing at all, I get the impression he thinks he is a lot better than he actually is, and he is no Adam Lambert!

Even though I thought Paul would go and wouldn't win, I'm sort of sad he has, thought he had a bit of a spark about him and I looked foward to watching him, even though his vocals weren't great, I did enjoy him singing Maggie May.

I think the competition will be poorer without Paul, not vocally maybe but as you say he gave a bit of life to a show that i found monotonous after he had performed on Weds. I knew hed go, hed already resigned himself to it, he was on first etc eetc and i think for the sake of his voice he needed to go so he can get the treatment he has needed right from the start (Nodes on his Vocal chords) My last hope for entertainment really is with James, i didnt like his song last Weds and i thought he got as many votes for Zakk Wylde as for his performance