Michael Mcintyre has been soo funny im so glad they hired him!!!

The Hoff has also been good and i like his interaction with the performers.

Amanda gives it stability and still makes it recognisable i dont think they could have changed the whole panel.

As much as i liek piers and simon , the show has worked with these three

Agreed.

It's a refreshing change.

I was bored, i'm not sure why that was. I don't think i'll watch again before the liveshows.

It's better without Morgan that's for sure. He's a smug bland git.

Im missing simon, i fink he wouldve ended sum of the rubbish acts quicker! so wouldve saved us watchin dem! but im likin michael, n yh hoffs ok n amandas ok

The forum seems to be quite againt Michael yet I found him simply amazing! Maybe its because I'm seeing him for the first time or something but I have to see the new panel is really good!

The only problem at the moment no standout genuinley talented acts have been shown, hopefully that can change

Absolutely love them - the show has a completely different feel without Simon.

I was too, but for me it was because of the acts. Nothing really new and no act was amazing. A bit lacklustre.

Having said that I didn't miss Cowell tonight and I thought McIntyre was great.

I would like Amanda to go and then Id be happy .....

Right now, I love all three judges. But with Cowell gone, there's nobody giving the contestants a reality check. The guy with the eyes popping out...seriously? Cowell would have rightfully told him where to go. There's nobody like that.

Hasselhoff and McIntyre do make things much more entertaining though.

I enjoyed the new judging panel and i also liked Michael, but the acts---oh dear :sleep: but hopefully it will get better

Far more entertaining with the new judges. Glad to see the back of Simon and Piers.

What ive gathered is the forum is usually against people dat are actually talented or the only good thing on a show..coz i like michael n so did alot of people. oh n u should watch some of michaels stand up shows his really funny!!

I'm still watching the main show (+1 'ing it) and much prefer Michael over Simon. He brings another edge to it and humour!! I don't even think Michael Mcintyre isthat funny or even like him.

Michael has a thumbs up from me ad Simon Cowell gets the buzzer!

Glad to get rid of Piers... I really liked the new panel (even the Hoff!) but I did miss Simon at some points

It worked. I didn't miss Simon's presence at all.

Michael is brilliant, the Hoff was surprisingly fun, and Amanda is Amanda - they work well as a panel. I really enjoyed it.

I really liked Michael, and the Hoff, and that's from someone who couldn't stand him on AGT!

I am really liking Michael M, infact all three judges seemed to "gel"(not the Essex meaning) sorry like on American Idol i am not missing Simon at all, and as for Piers Morgan i could not stand the prat anyway so with him off the panel is great!!

I think Michael's a good addition to the panel. The Hoff has been a bit pointless though. But it's still early days.

The main problem with this episode wasn't anything to do with the judges though, it was just that most of the acts were boring.

I'm a Michael McIntyre fan so I'm happy he's on the panel, and him Hasseelhoff and Amanda did well together and I'm liking it so far.

Felt for a while now.the REALLY nasty Simon Cowell Vanished years ago.
hes been living off that image for ages.

Both last years BGT and Xfactor wasnt worth him showing up.
As for Piers never did understand what made him a BGT judge??? he made some horrendous choices.

Simon wasnt missed one bit tonight and Think the same will happen in Xfactor people might be used to having him around but once they get used to the idea he wont be missed.

2nd show Cowell's dropped out of
2nd one he ain't been missed on

I prefer the show without Simon. I can't think who it was on here who said it last night, but Piers & Simon took the show and themselves far too seriously.

:sleep:

After first 5 minutes didn't miss him at all. Amanda is the lynchpin - The Hoff is just a weird American (they could def substitute him) can't understand why he's on the show and Michael McIntyre definitely added some humour.

So it's about the contestants for me anyway.

Didn't miss Simon at all. Ant n Dec are what keep me watching.

Completely agree.
I was a bit dubious about the Hoff, I'd seen some AGT and he kinda annoyed me, but he was surprisingly good last night.