Yes or no?

Simon was great, but he has lost it for me now. The change is fantastic! So, no from me.

Not sure! I'd prefer Simon to the hoff!!

but he's not too bad

nope.
hope he leaves Xfactor also.

We need judges with some fire in them not just there because hes signed a deal with ITV.
Cowell needs to realise hes run out of steam for the time being.

Agreed. We need fresh changes. The BGT change feels fantastic, hope the same happens to X Factor.

Nope! I've forgotten he even judged on the show. After last years x factor, he's shown how much he wants to manipulate the public and how much of a push over he is with a certain someone. A judge should be impartial and care about the show and the acts involved. Simon just seen pound signs as ever. His ego is far too big and I'm glad he's gone from the show.

If he was still on the show, I wouldn't watch it.

I love the new judges, sooooo funny!

No. The judging panel feels fresher and I like it. Now if they could get some half-decent acts on, it'd be perfect.

No - the panel's much better as it is. I kind of hope Simon doesn't return for the lives.

No. Sick to death of Cowell. He is as bored of judging as I am of him.

Yes, I have always liked Simon, his faces he pulls are sooo funny

He might be a control freak, but he reads the performances of the acts on his shows very well(most of the time anyway)

I've always usually agreed with Simon's opinions so yes. He was the only one to tell the dreadful acts they were poor when Amanda and Piers thought they were amazing.

I don't know if Michael or David will do that.

Yes, very much.

Not even a little bit

Love Simon, but I don't miss him on this show.

Miss him loads ~ but I read this week he will be back as a fourth judge for the live shows .

No. Used to like and respect him but his behaviour on last year's XF did it for me, can't stand him anymore. I'm liking the lineup of Amanda, Michael & Hoff.

It is more lighthearted than before now Simon isn't there. Same goes for American Idol.