Originally Posted by wizzywick:
“
I am sure ITV did a good job. They generally do. They are Britains second most important broadcaster and they have vast experience in doing these events.They're not going to put on a mediocre job! I didn't watch ITV so can't comment on what was better, but for all those berating the BBC, how much of it did you watch in order to come up with such a negative opinion?”
My short answer would be that the Beeb had the wrong people in the wrong locations.
Huw Edwards presented as though it was the funeral of Sir Winston Churchill, and I'd have thought a pairing with Sophie Raworth would have helped to lighten the atmosphere (the 8.30pm highlights show with them sat side-by-side was better). Fiona Bruce (who joyously presented Thursday night's News to a cheering crowd as if conducting an orchestra) was utterly wasted outside the Abbey, stuck with the occasional interview. I shall try and be nice and just say that Fearne Cotton didn't have a good day at the office.
ITV1 struck gold. Pip Schofield and Julie Etchingham worked a treat together (let's hope they aren't punished by being offered the Daybreak gig), a much lighter tone to proceedings as the day demanded. To prove that you can present outside your comfort zone, Mark Austin mingling with the crowd in The Mall made for telly to make everyone feel good. Plenty of others (e.g. Mary Nightingale and Alistair Stewart) brought the right sense of feel to the day.
And that was the difference. If you were looking for a channel to help you smile during Friday, you would have been looking at ITV1.