• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • Entertainment
  • Music
Oasis vs The Beatles vs Michael Jackson vs Elvis
<<
<
1 of 13
>>
>
Pacman 2011
24-04-2011
What is your personal opinion and what is facts?

Who really was or is the best!?

Baring in mind none of these singers or bands exsist anymore as they have disbanded or died
Jane Doh!
24-04-2011
Oasis are ok, Elvis is ok, the other two are overrated.
Smithy1204
24-04-2011
For me, personally:

The Beatles
Oasis
Michael Jackson
Elvis Presley

I'd guess a lot of people would put Oasis further down, but I'm putting them high up just because I love some of their older stuff so much (What's the Story (Morning Glory) album, etc).

I'm not a fan of Elvis at all though, I've only got one song by him on my iPod. But hey, personal preferences.
Jennymoo
24-04-2011
My personal opinion is Oasis. I guess who was actually the best would go by record sales. I don't know. I love Oasis, they provided the soundtrack of my youth.
Gawge
24-04-2011
Oasis are decent, but completely overrated. Still, I really enjoy some of their earlier stuff.

The order for me:

The Beatles
Elvis
Oasis
Michael Jackson
Paradise_Lost
24-04-2011
The Beatles
Elvis


MJ


























Oasis.
Pacman 2011
24-04-2011
Originally Posted by Jane Doh!:
“Oasis are ok, Elvis is ok, the other two are overrated.”

Why do you think they are over rated?

Originally Posted by Jennymoo:
“My personal opinion is Oasis. I guess who was actually the best would go by record sales. I don't know. I love Oasis, they provided the soundtrack of my youth.”

Love Oasis to, shame they have split!

Originally Posted by Gawge:
“Oasis are decent, but completely overrated. Still, I really enjoy some of their earlier stuff.

The order for me:

The Beatles
Elvis
Oasis
Michael Jackson”


Why is MJ last lol
Gawge
24-04-2011
Originally Posted by Pacman 2011:
“Why is MJ last lol”

I was seriously debating putting MJ 3rd and Oasis last. I'd probably say that Michael Jackson is "better" than Oasis, however I probably prefer Oasis to MJ.

The Beatles and Elvis are considerably better than the other two though.
Pacman 2011
24-04-2011
Originally Posted by Gawge:
“I was seriously debating putting MJ 3rd and Oasis last. I'd probably say that Michael Jackson is "better" than Oasis, however I probably prefer Oasis to MJ.

The Beatles and Elvis are considerably better than the other two though.”

Is that because the 2 you put at the bottom are the same to that were inspired by the top 2 you choose?
ManUtdFan-92
24-04-2011
I don't think Oasis should be in the same poll as those 3 personally. Maybe Marley or Sinatra.
Pacman 2011
24-04-2011
Originally Posted by ManUtdFan-92:
“I don't think Oasis should be in the same poll as those 3 personally. Maybe Marley or Sinatra.”

I will add Marley and Madonna to the list!
Wayne Dibbly
24-04-2011
Oasis shouldn't be on the list in that company. A 2nd rate Beatles/Lennon tribute band.
NostalgiaMan
24-04-2011
Out of those, Michael Jackson. But yeah Oasis seems a bit of a random choice. Yes, great britpop band, but if Oasis are in there, why aren't Stone Roses or Blur, for example

Always thought Elvis was overrated. Maybe it's because it was so different and new back then, or because his act was revolutionary for the time, but I don't rate him.
Sassernach
24-04-2011
Originally Posted by Pacman 2011:
“What is your personal opinion and what is facts?

Who really was or is the best!?

Baring in mind none of these singers or bands exsist anymore as they have disbanded or died ”

It is unfair to compare these as they were from different eras.
The Beatles help set the path for Oasis and bands like them.
Elvis probably would not have been so big but for Jerry lee Lewis marrying his teenage cousin.
Michael Jackson again another type of music. As they were all famous and their music is still played I cannot see that we can say any are lacking.

I have my own favourite musicians but I cannot pull down one artist at the cost of another. We should appreciate the artists and their talents.

Pacman 2011
24-04-2011
Originally Posted by NostalgiaMan:
“Out of those, Michael Jackson. But yeah Oasis seems a bit of a random choice. Yes, great britpop band, but if Oasis are in there, why aren't Stone Roses or Blur, for example

Always thought Elvis was overrated. Maybe it's because it was so different and new back then, or because his act was revolutionary for the time, but I don't rate him.”

Because Oasis achieved more then Stone Roses and Blur plus the list would take forever.

Originally Posted by Sassernach:
“It is unfair to compare these as they were from different eras.
The Beatles help set the path for Oasis and bands like them.
Elvis probably would not have been so big but for Jerry lee Lewis marrying his teenage cousin.
Michael Jackson again another type of music. As they were all famous and their music is still played I cannot see that we can say any are lacking.

I have my own favourite musicians but I cannot pull down one artist at the cost of another. We should appreciate the artists and their talents.

”

Aka sitting on the fence where your opinion counts
darkmoth
24-04-2011
Elvis ftw
JohnnyForget
24-04-2011
1. Elvis Presley (1954 to 1958)

2. The Beatles

3. Elvis Costello

4. Oasis

5. Elvis Presley (1959 to 1977)

6. Michael Jackson
eliana
24-04-2011
The Beatles and Elvis.

Big space etc

The other lot.....
Pacman 2011
25-04-2011
What ages are you?

I like ONE Elvis song and ONE Beatles song.

Oasis and MJ are what I know.
sionnaigh
25-04-2011
Oasis - my favourite group. For my money they had two of the best albums ever put together in DM and MG.

The Beatles - massive Beatles fan since I (and they!) were young. Some of their stuff hasn't stood the test of time but some still rocks to this day.

Michael Jackson - not a huge fan but liked some of his earlier stuff (probably up to, and including, Thriller)

Elvis Presley - never been a fan. Like a couple of tracks but that's it.
_drak
25-04-2011
Oasis, are you having a laugh.
gemma-the-husky
25-04-2011
look

The Beatles
Elvis

seminal influences in music

maybe you can add the Beach Boys, and maybe you need a R&B man also - not sure who - some say Chuck Berry, although he wasnt as prolific hitwise.


Oasis and MJ don't fit this.
robo2
25-04-2011
Originally Posted by Pacman 2011:
“What ages are you?

I like ONE Elvis song and ONE Beatles song.

Oasis and MJ are what I know.”

you do realise that most oasis songs are mediocre rip offs of the beatles, the rest are mediocre rip offs of slade and status quo
mbos
25-04-2011
The Gaslight Anthem
Beatles
MJ
Oasis
Elvis.
Caltonfan
25-04-2011
Oasis are my favourite group of all time but they wouldnt exist without The Beatles, so have to put the Beatles first.

Michael Jackson I cant stand, never seen the appeal of his music.

Elvis not a big fan but he wass better than Jackson
<<
<
1 of 13
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map