• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
The Doctor Who Series 6 Scoresheet Thread
<<
<
16 of 16
>>
>
davrosdodebird
02-10-2011
The Impossible Astronaut 10/10
Day of the Moon 8/10
Curse of the Black Spot 9/10
The Doctor's Wife 9/10
The Rebel Flesh 9/10
The Almost People 10/10
A Good Man Goes to War 8/10
Let's Kill Hitler 6/10
Night Terrors 7/10
The Girl Who Waited 8/10
The God Complex 4/10
Closing Time 10/10
The Wedding of River Song 10/10

This was the hardest episode to score. It was certainly fun to watch, and I felt that every detail was well handled, from the wedding of convenience that the Doctor/ River had, to the moving skulls, and to the Brigadier's death being used as the one thing that would get the Doctor to focus and stop running

That said, the one fault I found with this episode was that, despite answering all my questions, it felt too detached from the rest of the series, and so did not feel like the culmination of events thus far as much as a standalone episode.

I love the focus on the Docotr's identity at the end, and that the Doctor is not going to be portrayed as the tragic Demi God that we have seen since 2005. The Doctor is far more effective when he is an unkown wandering about the universe in his blue box.

I am also slightly concerned that Amy and Rory's ultimate fate was left unresolved, but this episode was a joy to watch so I am not too concerned 10/10

Series score: 108/130 - Average Score 8.3/10 (series 5 average was 8.1/10)
daveyboy7472
02-10-2011
The Impossible Astronaut: 6/10
Day Of The Moon: 8/10
The Curse Of The Black Spot 8/10
The Doctor's Wife 9/10
The Rebel Flesh 5/10
The Almost People 8/10
A Good Man Goes To War 7/10
Let's Kill Hitler 10/10
Night Terrors-7/10
The Girl Who Waited-9/10
The God Complex-7/10
Closing Time-7/10
The Wedding Of River Song 7/10

Could and should have been better than it was. But it wasn't awful by any means.
Jules 1
02-10-2011
The Impossible Astronaut 6.5/10
Day of the Moon 9/10
Curse of the Black Spot 6/10
The Doctor's Wife 7/10
The Rebel Flesh 9/10
The Almost People 9/10
A Good Man Goes To War 7/10
Let's Kill Hitler 9.5/10
Night Terrors: 5/10
The Girl Who Waited: 8/10
The God Complex: 6/10
Closing Time: 4.5/10
The Wedding of River Song 8/10

I liked the final episode and as I said in the main threaded there were some really nice touches but I don't personally paid off the emotional involvement of the arc this series.
Season average 7.3/10
TheSilentFez
25-12-2011
The Impossible Astronaut: 10/10
Day of the Moon: 10/10
The Curse of the Black Spot: 7/10
The Doctor's Wife: 10/10
The Rebel Flesh: 9/10
The Almost People: 9/10
A Good Man Goes to War: 10/10
Let's Kill Hitler: 9½/10
Night Terrors: 9/10
The Girl Who Waited: 10/10
The God Complex: 10/10
Closing Time: 8/10
The Wedding of River Song:10/10

The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe: 8/10

I think this episode is technically grouped with series 7, but seeing as we'll have to wait until October or so for that, I thought I would just post my score here.

So overall, this year's festive special was pretty nice. By all means not perfect, but a decent and fun Christmas episode. I'll give it an 8/10
Mystical123
25-12-2011
Originally Posted by TheSilentFez:
“So overall, this year's festive special was pretty nice. By all means not perfect, but a decent and fun Christmas episode.”

I'd agree with that, I thought it was a bit of a rubbish storyline in terms of the 'villain', but the slushy ending was perfect for Christmas, and an Amy and Rory cameo is always welcome

A standalone 7ish out of 10, but not so much in comparison with series 6 as a whole. I don't think it's a particularly useful comparison to make though, so I won't add it on to my series 6 scores.
MrPond
25-12-2011
The Impossible Austronaut: 9.5/10
Day of the Moon: 9.5/10
The Curse of the Black Spot: 8/10
The Doctor's Wife: 9/10
The Rebel Flesh: 7/10
The Almost People: 8/10
A Good Man Goes To War: 10/10
------
Let's Kill Hitler: 10/10
Night Terrors: 8/10
The Girl Who Waited: 10/10
The God Complex: 9/10
Closing Time: 7/10
The Wedding of River Song: 10/10
------
The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe: 8.5/10
CAMERA OBSCURA
26-12-2011
The Impossible Astronaut 5/10
Day of the Moon 4/10
Curse of the Black Spot 4/10
The Doctor's Wife 10/10
The Rebel Flesh 6/10
The Almost People 5/10
A Good Man Goes To War 4/10
Let's Kill Hitler: 4/10
Night Terrors 8/10
The Girl Who Waited 7/10
The God Complex 8/10
Closing Time 7/10
The Wedding of River Song 5/10
The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe 6/10
Josh Pinder
26-12-2011
As with others i wont add it to Series 6 as such. But i did really love the episode and will easily rewatch it

I feel Christmas Carol and Christmas Invasion were the only "perfect" Who episodes for Christmas Special...but The Doctor, The Widow And the Wardrobe is up there too

8.5/10
Whovian1109
27-12-2011
Watching the opening two parter as we speak but still...

The Impossible Astronaut 10/10- I thought it was fantastic.
Day of the Moon 9/10- Very good, not quite as good as TIA
Curse of the Black Spot 7/10- Decent as a standalone.
The Doctor's Wife 8/10- Again, a solid episode.
The Rebel Flesh 7/10- Underwhelming but good.
The Almost People 8/10- A decent episode and a stunning cliffhanger.
A Good Man Goes To War 7/10- Not as good as I'd hoped.
Let's Kill Hitler- 9/10 Very strong episode. Loved it.
Night Terrors 6/10- Worst episode of the series IMO.
The Girl Who Waited 8/10- A good ep with a decent ending.
The God Complex 8/10 - The ending pushed it up to an 8.
Closing Time 7/10- Good ep but let down by the poor finish.
Wedding of River Song 9/10- Loved the reveal, brilliant fun.

Total score: 103/130 Average of just below 8.

I'm not sure if to include it here but I will anyway, The Doctor, The Widow and The Wardrobe gets a 6/10. If I'm honest, it's dull and would've got a 5 if not for Amy's appearance at the end to save it.
Vabosity
27-12-2011
The Impossible Astronaut: 10/10

Day Of The Moon: 10/10

Curse Of The Black Spot: 7/10

The Doctor's Wife: 10/10

The Rebel Flesh: 4/10

The Almost People: 7/10

A Good Man Goes To War: 10/10

Let's Kill Hitler: 10/10

Night Terrors: 5/10

The Girl Who Waited: 8/10

The God Complex: 7/10

Closing Time: 7/10

The Wedding Of River Song: 10/10

The Doctor, The Widow And The Wardrobe: 8/10


Series 6 was magnificent.
MrPond
27-12-2011
I did post the other day, but after tweaking my scores, I've come to these final scores.

The Impossible Austronaut - 10/10 - Best series opener of Nu-Who! Loved everyone second of it!
Day of the Moon - 9.5/10 - Again, another brilliant episode, not quite as good as TIA.
The Curse of the Black Spot - 8/10 - A nice episode, not much more.
The Doctor's Wife - 9/10 - An episode I could watch 100+ more times without getting bored. Beautiful!
The Rebel Flesh - 7/10 - One of the poorest of the series, waste of an episode.
The Almost People - 7.5 - Slightly better. The last 5 minutes was better than the whole episode. The whole two-parter could have been done in 1 episode!
A Good Man Goes To War - 10/10 - Brilliant episode, brilliant reveal/
Let's Kill Hitler - 10/10 - Amazing way to bring us back from the break. Amazing episode!
Night Terrors - 8/10 - Bit of a letdown on what could have been a great episode, but still enjoyable!
The Girl Who Waited - 10/10 - Beautiful thoughtout episode, really touching and a brilliant ending.
The God Complex - 8.5/10 - Lovely episode, brilliant storyline.
Closing Time - 7/10 - meh episode. One of the weakest episodes! Ending was brilliant though, best moments of the series!
The Wedding of River Song - my favourite episode I think! Full to the brim of amazing-ness. Fantastic!
-----------
The Doctor, The Widow. and the Wardrobe - 8.5/10 - one of my favourite Christmas episodes! Enjoyable.

Overall (not including TD,TW,atW) score - 8.8/10
Josh Pinder
27-12-2011
I cannot get over how immense the Series 6 Box Set is! It is amazing and i do love the art cards in the special edition...like the ones in the series 5 special "crack metallic" edition they are so so cool!

And i love when you fold out the box inside it makes a full epic picture of the cast and a mini comic strip by the episode guide. Also love the detail on the main menus and the extras.

While i do know i will enjoy series 7....series 6 is definitely gonna be the one to match for me....my favourite series of the show (of course series 5 and 1 just behind )

But seriously what a fantastic set of episodes for a series to boast On re-watch here tiz -

A Christmas Carol - 9/10
The Impossible Astronaut - 10/10
Day Of The Moon - 10/10
Curse Of The Black Spot - 8/10
The Doctors Wife - 10/10
The Rebel Flesh - 8/10
The Almost People - 9/10
A good man goes to war - 10/10
Lets Kill Hitler - 10/10
Night Terrors - 8.5/10
The girl who waited - 10/10
The god complex - 10/10
Closing Time - 9/10
The Wedding Of River Song - 10/10
----
The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe - 8.5/10
<<
<
16 of 16
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map