Originally Posted by little-monster:
“I couldn't disagree more. Chicago Fire is hardly groundbreaking but it's far from generic. How many shows are there about firefighters? None. Only before, there was the cable drama Rescue me. I would say it's spin-off shows Chicago PD and Chicago Med are generic.
Underneath it all, Limitless is a generic crime drama but it has slight twist of the main character having enhanced abilities. All of which has been done several times before.”
As I said, what makes Chicago Fire "different from" the Chicago trilogy staple and from most dramas we see on TV is the fact that it is about firefighters. There isn't any show that takes that as its subject matter. But when you look at its theme and plot structure it IS generic and middle-of-road, much like Chicago PD and Meds is (in the case of CPD) and will be (on the caee of CMed). CF does nothing new that we haven't or don't see in other comparable dramas that focus on medicine or the police. If Chicago Fire was centred on two or three female firefighters and did a kind of Cagney and Lacey type theme with it, with one of the females as Chief and the tables were turned and shaken up a little w/o having to reducing them to baby-makers and lonely *spinsters* looking for lurve and a maannn, then I would say it was unconventional. But it isn't. The generic conventions are just as soapy as Chicago PD except it has a lot more energy to it than its Chicago counter-part. As it is, Chicago Fire killed off its really interesting don't give-a-damn lesbian character, Shay. (Perhaps their only interesting character to date.) Her dynamic and friendship with Severide was so different and unusual. And it added so much to Severide as a character, and typically a good-looking, manly, heterosexual male. But they killed her off - quelle surprise! and so conventional and generic. And the writers have done nothing with Severide other than to have him look out for, rescue and have sex with beautiful blonde women. (Does that behaviour have anything to do with the loss of Shay? Is it as psychologically effecting as that? I doubt the writers will even go there. So again, if they don't, Severide is so generic, so conventional: single hsndsome man shags beautiful women. Yawn.) Gabby Dawson, the only female firefighter, is now pregnant and now has transferred to investigating arson, and this after all the writers put us through rooting for her as she was battling to become that rare species in an overwhelming male dominated profession: a woman firefighter. With her now pregnant, that characte- turn has become conventional and generic - here's a woman; what should we do with her; oh, I know, let's make her get pregnant. No doubt some way down the plot line she will lose the child anyway, whether she was fighting fires or not.
So, sorry, I hate to say it, but I don't agree with you on this, LM. Chicago Fire is generic and conventional when you break it down to its individual parts.
PS: Agree with on Limitless. But what makes it a little different cop shows is its underlying mystery sub-plot that functions outside the conventions of an ordinary "investigate and find the bad guy" cop show.