the hoff
amanda
cowell


mcintyre is soooooooooooo annoying

why the hell should he be judging talent

Being the most talented of the lot, he does have a right to be there, in my opinion.

He is the only one with talent. Then we will have three talentless twits.

I sencond that petition !!

He got too big for his boots and calling Amanda Mandy all the time kissing her ar.. all the time, argh, the guy is desperate not to lose the new gig

I think Michael is fantastic. Funny, sweet and honest.

Yes axe the actual judge who is probably the one who doesn't get involved in all the backstage production manipulation.....

and of course has an actual talent. Unlike Simon and Amanda Mcintyre sold out Wembley by himself.

I love him, he's great.

micheals the only one i would have kept.

hes honest but when he needs to say something bad he adds humour to diffuse an awkward situation so the contestant goes away smiling instead of feeling bad.

The hoff is just useless with most british moments going over his head. And Amanda just hasnt got the people skills, she always comes across as a complete bitch. And Cowell just doesnt care anymore.

At least Micheal has a sense of the absurd for the whole thing.

I'd rather have Michael than the Hoffman

I used to really like mcintyre, I used to really respect him as a comedian,

but now he is just cashing in on his fame by appearing on this show, making cheap, average jokes when he is giving his verdict,

if they need to get rid of anyone it's the hoff - he serves no purpose

I think he's a better television personality than he is a comedian. Give him more freedom.

The thing is he's always had a good sense of timing and the mechanics of how to put an act together, but his material is often weak or obvious (Stewart Lee did a nice take off recently). If they let him speak naturally, his eye for detail would come across insightfully, I think, as he's a very studied performer, in his mannerisms, and that comes from observing what others do well, and what can be improved. It's that kind of ethic that elevates his act far beyond what his writing merits, and he deserves some respect for that, I think.

Either lose the Hoff who has no reason the be there and is useless, or Amanda whose the main reason so much **** gets through and so many of the good acts are cut

Michael is the best judge, I dont think David provides anything to the panel really so if any judge is to go i think he will. After all he has been moved to the end of the panel.

I totally agree! Michael is the only one I would keep, he's the only genuine member of the panel.

Nooo. Michael is amazing on the panel!

I really like Michael! Keep him!

Panel worked much better without Cowell IMO.

Noooo!! just because you dont like him plenty people like him so get off his back. his actually talented and nice to watch, his really genuine

Mike is the only one with talent

Mike - Comedy
Mandy - No Talent
David Hassolholf - No Talent
Si Cowell - Guessing (not a real talent)

Michael has made me laugh more than any other judge. As mentioned, I also love the fact that he can diffuse the awkward moments and negative comments with a good line, especially the ones directed at Simon. Plus he is the only member of the panel who has actually been on the Royal Variety Performance!!!! Who better???

I honestly can't stand his middle class slightly smug comedy routines that fail to make me laugh ...... but on this (I've only been watching it since the Semi Final stages) I really like him and his comments.

NOOO!! Get rid of Cowell!!

I much preferred it without him - Michael actually makes me laugh. Maybe get rid of The Hoff though.

Michael, Amanda, Louis

For me,he is the worst thing about this series.His annoying scrappy doo voice grates on me and does he really have to attempt to make a joke every-time he is spoken to?Perhaps the worst comedian I have ever been unfortunate enough to listen to

Kick out Amanda and the Hoff

Replace the Hoff with Louie Walsh full time, or bring Piers back, dunno who would replace Amanda though pretty much any woman in the world would be better than her