Love Mcintyre on the panel!

I want the Hoff gone, never ever liked him.. McIntyre has made the show this series and has definitely outshone Cowell and Hoff.. Holden quite surprised me tonight during the performance.. I still can't bring myself to like her, especially with that cackle she appears to have picked up along the way

I don't know, I mean he's the most talented out of all the judges but since when did you have to be talented to judge a reality tv show.

you obviously are the most uptight dullest person ever then bec he's brilliant

Yes, me to

As founder of The Michael McIntyre Appreciation Thread I say keep him and get rid of the other three.

The Mack must stay!

He's great. If you must get rid of one, why him?

Yeah thats good logic, axe the only person who deserves to judge talent.

He is so funny

I definitely think Louis would be marvellous as a full time judge on BGT !!! I mean I love him on x-factor too... well just love Louis full stop. But.... with Dannii, Cheryl, and even SImon gone.... the formula is gone on X-factor, and on the few occasions I have seen him stand in on BGT.. he was terrific !!

Daily Star tomorrow http://news.sky.com/sky-news/content...4/16003205.jpg "more judges face the axe"

I like Michael as a judge though sometimes he makes bizarre decisions. He likes the 'funny' acts who aren't actually funny too much.

I think he's great, it's The Hoff who really needs to go.

I guess Micheal will have to go back to his day job of selling out the o2 arena

He has one 'talent' and that is as a comedian.

Don't give me that crap about anyone can judge singing etc, if that is the case of singing shows anyone would be the judge, but they're not, they are all in the music biz!

McIntyre has little knowledge about singing dancing etc, and just comments on the act themselves. It's pretty boring.

Amanda performed at the Royal Variety Performance years ago.

I love Michael. He's a brilliant judge and adds lot of humour to the panel. I also think Amanda is great and fills her role perfectly. I genuinely don't understand why people have a problem with her. The Hoff is the only dead weight and he doesn't add much at all.

He's by far the best judge and I thought he'd be annoying. Guy is quick, funny, witty, honest, happy and smarter than Simon on that panel.

I only watch because of Michael McIntyre.

Please don't criticise me, but they should keep all three.

I'd like to see the new judges stay for more than one series at least, and Michael is the only funny one out of all of them to be honest.

What he's hillarious, Cowell should have stayed in America IMO

You want rid of the only judge with any talent and has rid us of Piers Morgan?

MM is terrific, throws in some amusing lines throughout.

If you're axing one of the four judges it would have to be Cowell who is adding very little this series but I think 4 is working better than 3.

Louis, Cheryl and Michael would be an awesome panel

Im actually annoyed The Hoff has received allot of hate when it was MICHAEL & AMANDA who overuled david and put through that stupid terminator guy and other useless acts.

So why were stupid people calling in and apparently saying mean things to him on the streets?

Amanda Holden is seriously retarded. Its very clear shes not interested in chosing TALENTED acts... just flirting with cowell and getting dressed up for primetime tv... Urgh.

I honestly think Simon Cowell is the worst judge now. They dont need him as a judge. I think I am just so over him now. Always the same comments, always the same "my opinion matters more than anyone else's" attitude. Away to XFactor USA with you, boring man!!

I think the worst judge is the hoff, amanda or simon. Lol they are all crap, michael is the only reason i can still bring myself to watch this fixed show!